🗞️ Story file #728
US envoy Witkoff meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine peace talks
Oct 20, 7 PM ET to Oct 21, 8 PM ET · 1 outlet not rated for lean
📰 43 outlets carried it ⚖️ 🫏19 · 11 · 12🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 1 day on the front pages 📈 42 front pages at once, at its peak 📺 76 min of TV captions 📻 8 radio newscasts 🧵 9 of 10 parts of a saga
👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through
TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is
part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say
how each is made.
📰 Spread
the front pages that ran it, hour by hour
Oct 21 6 AM 12 PM 6 PM 20 40 left center right not rated
Front pages carrying it at each hourly run, Oct 20, 7 PM to Oct 21, 8 PM ET (peak 40), by the outlets' lean:
left · center · right · not rated
Oct 20 12 PM Oct 21 12 PM WSJThe Wall Street Journal The Wall Street Journal, Oct 19, 6:00 PM ET: Trump Says He’s Open to Talks With the Leaders of Russia and China The Washington TimesThe Washington Times The Washington Times, Oct 19, 7:00 PM ET: Trump open to Putin, Xi summit on ending Ukraine war without Zelenskyy New York PostNew York Post New York Post, Oct 19, 7:00 PM ET: Trump again blows up on Zelensky, insists Russia ‘has been fine on Ukraine’ New York Post, Oct 21, 10:00 AM ET: Trump envoy Steve Witkoff praises Putin as ‘humanitarian’ as Ukraine peace talks hang in the balance New York Post, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin agrees to trilateral talks with Ukraine, US to end war New York Post, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: US special envoy Steve Witkoff complimented Russian dictator Vladimir Putin as a “humanitarian” during their meeting in St. Petersburg — as President Trump desperately tries to get Russia back to the negotiating table to end the Ukraine war. New York Post, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Table for three Putin agrees to trilateral talks with Ukraine, US to end war New York Post, Oct 21, 5:00 PM ET: Putin agrees to trilateral talks with Ukraine, US to end war — with a catch HuffPostHuffPost HuffPost, Oct 19, 9:00 PM ET: Trump Says Russia's Been 'Fine On Ukraine' As He Rips Zelenskyy HuffPost, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: Witkoff Asks Putin To Resume Three-Way Ukraine Peace Talks, Secures Release Of U.S. Citizen HuffPost, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Zelenskyy Says He Would Accept Deal That Freezes War Along Current Frontlines HuffPost, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Trump’s Ukraine Envoy Faces Backlash For Calling Putin ‘A Humanitarian’ TimeTime Time, Oct 20, 10:00 AM ET: Trump Open to ‘Denuclearization’ Summit with Putin and Xi Financial TimesFinancial Times Financial Times, Oct 20, 12:00 PM ET: Witkoff meets Zelenskyy before travelling to Russia Financial Times, Oct 21, 2:00 PM ET: Trump envoy floats Ukraine talks and summit with Putin and Xi The HillThe Hill The Hill, Oct 20, 1:00 PM ET: Witkoff, Kushner to meet with Zelensky The Hill, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Zelensky says he’d be open to freezing front lines to end Russia war The GuardianThe Guardian The Guardian, Oct 20, 4:00 PM ET: US has resumed sharing intelligence with Ukraine about Russian strikes, says Zelenskyy The Guardian, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: Putin orders release of jailed American as he meets Trump envoy for Ukraine talks RFE/RLRadio Free Europe Radio Liberty Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, Oct 20, 4:00 PM ET: After Oslo Talks, Zelenskyy Thanks US As Missile Intelligence 'Works Now' Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, Oct 21, 4:00 AM ET: US Envoy Witkoff Arrives In Russia After Zelenskyy Talks On Ukraine Peace Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, Oct 21, 9:00 AM ET: US Envoy Witkoff Meets Putin After Zelenskyy Talks On Ukraine Peace Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: After Witkoff Meeting, Putin 'Ready To Resume' US-Led Peace Talks With Ukraine NewsmaxNewsmax Newsmax, Oct 20, 4:00 PM ET: Envoy to Offer Putin Direct Talks With Trump, Zelenskyy Newsmax, Oct 21, 5:00 AM ET: Trump Envoy Witkoff to Meet Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine war Talks Newsmax, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: Trump Envoy Witkoff Meets Putin in Push for Ukraine Peace Newsmax, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin Agrees in Principle to Resume Ukraine Peace Talks Newsmax, Oct 21, 2:00 PM ET: Putin Agrees to Restart Peace Talks on Ukraine War Newsmax, Oct 21, 6:00 PM ET: Trump Stops Short of Calling Putin 'Humanitarian' Newsmax, Oct 21, 8:00 PM ET: Russia 'Ready' to Resume Trilateral Talks, but Cool on Ukraine Deal Chances The WeekThe Week The Week, Oct 20, 6:00 PM ET: Morning Report Trump says Russia ‘has been fine on Ukraine’ Yahoo NewsYahoo News Yahoo News, Oct 20, 6:00 PM ET: Trump says Russia 'has been fine on Ukraine' as he makes deals with Putin Yahoo News, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Putin agrees to new Ukraine peace talks as Trump turns up pressure on Zelensky ReutersReuters Reuters, Oct 20, 7:00 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff to meet Putin, Trump presses Kyiv to settle Reuters, Oct 20, 8:00 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff to meet Putin, Trump presses Kyiv to settle - Reuters Reuters, Oct 21, 4:00 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff arrives in St Petersburg for talks with Putin Reuters, Oct 21, 9:00 AM ET: Trump envoy asks Putin to resume three-way Ukraine peace talks, secures release of US citizen Reuters, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Russia is willing in principle to join new Ukraine peace talks in November, Kremlin says Reuters, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Putin agrees to resume 3-way peace talks with Ukraine and US Reuters, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Putin agrees to resume 3-way peace talks with Ukraine and US - Reuters BBCBBC BBC, Oct 21, 1:00 AM ET: US envoy to meet Putin in Russia as Zelensky says intelligence sharing 'works now' BBC, Oct 21, 3:00 AM ET: US envoy arrives in Russia ahead of meeting with Putin as Zelensky says intelligence sharing 'works now' BBC, Oct 21, 5:00 AM ET: Zelensky says intelligence sharing 'works now' as US envoy to meet Putin in Russia BBC, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Russia ready to resume talks with Ukraine and US to end war BBC, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Russia says it is ready to resume talks with Ukraine and US to end war CNNCNN CNN, Oct 21, 4:00 AM ET: Breaking News US envoy Witkoff lands in Russia for talks with Putin CNN, Oct 21, 6:00 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with Putin in effort to advance proposals to end war in Ukraine ABC NewsABC News ABC News, Oct 21, 5:00 AM ET: Witkoff arrives in St. Petersburg for Putin talks, Kremlin aide says The SunThe Sun The Sun, Oct 21, 6:00 AM ET: DON’S DEAL Trump’s envoy to meet Putin with new plan to end war as president warns Zelensky The Sun, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: DON’S DEAL Trump’s envoy meets Putin with new plan to end war as president warns Zelensky THE crunch talks come after a testing few weeks for the US-Ukrainian relationship. The Sun, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: TRUCE HOPES Putin 'ready' to resume talks with US & Ukraine IN WEEKS after 3hr showdown News NationNews Nation News Nation, Oct 21, 6:00 AM ET: Russia releases imprisoned American man, US envoy Witkoff says on visit to St. Petersburg News Nation, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin agrees to resume trilateral talks to end war in Ukraine News Nation, Oct 21, 4:00 PM ET: Trump special envoy Steve Witkoff praises Putin as 'humanitarian' New York TimesNew York Times New York Times, Oct 21, 6:00 AM ET: An American Teacher Went to Ukraine. Now He’s in a Russian Prison. APAP AP, Oct 21, 7:00 AM ET: Trump envoy Witkoff meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine war talks AP, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin agrees to resume trilateral talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says AP, Oct 21, 5:00 PM ET: Russia agrees to resume three-way talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says IJRIndependent Journal Review Independent Journal Review, Oct 21, 7:00 AM ET: Witkoff Arrives in St. Petersburg for Putin Talks BloombergBloomberg Bloomberg, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: Putin Meets US Envoy Witkoff to Discuss Ukraine Peace Proposals Bloomberg, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin Says Russia Ready for New Peace Talks with US, Ukraine Bloomberg, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Putin Says Russia Ready for New Peace Talks With US, Ukraine Bloomberg, Oct 21, 3:00 PM ET: Putin Releases Hostage to US, Earning Praise as Humanitarian AxiosAxios Axios, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: Witkoff asks Putin to resume direct peace talks, Russia releases U.S. detainee Axios, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Putin tells Witkoff he is ready to resume direct peace talks, Russia releases U.S. detainee SemaforSemafor Semafor, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: US envoy Steve Witkoff holds talks with Putin The IndependentThe Independent The Independent, Oct 21, 8:00 AM ET: Trump's envoy says he hopes to restart three-way talks with Russia and Ukraine The Independent, Oct 21, 4:00 PM ET: Trump’s special envoy tells Putin he is a ‘humanitarian’ CBS NewsCBS News CBS News, Oct 21, 9:00 AM ET: Witkoff says he hopes Ukraine included in U.S., Russia talks Military.comMilitary.com Military.com, Oct 21, 10:00 AM ET: Trump Envoy Witkoff Meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine War Talks Military.com, Oct 21, 3:00 PM ET: Putin Agrees to Resume Three-Way Talks on Ukraine War With Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin Says CNBCCNBC CNBC, Oct 21, 10:00 AM ET: Witkoff calls Putin a 'humanitarian' at Russia peace talks without Ukraine Red StateRed State Red State, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: This May Be It: Putin Agrees to Peace Talks, Zelensky Open to Deal That Freezes Lines Nick Arama Red State, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: This May Be It: Putin Agrees to Peace Talks, Zelensky Open to Deal That Freezes Lines Red State, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Ukraine This May Be It: Putin Agrees to Peace Talks, Zelensky Open to Deal That Freezes Lines Nick Arama Scripps NewsScripps News Scripps News, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Russia Putin agrees to resume Ukraine peace talks after meeting with Trump envoy AP via Scripps News Group Chicago TribuneChicago Tribune Chicago Tribune, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Russia President Vladimir Putin agrees to resume trilateral talks on Ukraine war, Kremlin says PBS NewsHourPBS NewsHour PBS NewsHour, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin agrees to resume trilateral Russia-Ukraine-U.S. talks next month MediaiteMediaite Mediaite, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: JUST IN: Vladimir Putin Agrees to Restart Peace Talks With Ukraine, U.S. Mediaite, Oct 21, 2:00 PM ET: Vance Downplays Criticism of Witkoff’s ‘Humanitarian’ Putin Praise: ‘We Should All Be Celebrating’ Fox NewsFox News Fox News, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Ukraine's Zelenskyy describes potential path to ceasefire in war with Russia Fox News, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Ukraine's Zelenskyy open to freezing front lines in ceasefire with Russia Fox News, Oct 21, 12:00 PM ET: Zelenskyy tells 'FOX & Friends' what he's willing to accept for ceasefire with Russia Just the NewsJust the News Just the News, Oct 21, 11:00 AM ET: Putin agrees to resume talks with U.S., Ukraine The Epoch TimesThe Epoch Times The Epoch Times, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Witkoff, Putin Meet for Talks on Ukraine in St. Petersburg Washington ExaminerWashington Examiner Washington Examiner, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Zelensky says he would accept peace deal freezing war along current lines Star TribuneStar Tribune Star Tribune, Oct 21, 2:00 PM ET: Putin agrees to resume three-way talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says The Daily WireThe Daily Wire The Daily Wire, Oct 21, 2:00 PM ET: Putin Agrees To Three-Way Peace Talks After Meeting With Trump Envoys The Daily Wire, Oct 21, 3:00 PM ET: Putin Agrees To Three-Way Ukraine Peace Talks After Meeting With Trump Envoys Foreign PolicyForeign Policy Foreign Policy, Oct 21, 4:00 PM ET: The U.S. Is Pushing for Ukraine Peace Talks. Is Putin Interested? Foreign Policy, Oct 21, 5:00 PM ET: Witkoff Pushes Putin to Restart Peace Talks and 3 more 📺 TV BBC News, 10:04 PM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT Russia after meeting Z. Zelensky. BBC NEWS Oslo, 20 October BBC News, 10:04 PM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT Russia after meeting Z. Zelensky. BBC NEWS Oslo, 20 October BBC News, 10:20 PM ET: Vice Chair City Official speaks to Dubai BBC News, 10:20 PM ET: Vice Chair City Official speaks to Dubai BBC News, 10:21 PM ET: Vice Chair City Official speaks to Dubai BBC News, 11:01 PM ET: ZELENSKY TO VISIT RUSSIA after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 11:02 PM ET: Zelensky calls for trilateral talks with US and Russia BBC News, 11:04 PM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT Russia after meeting Zelensky. BBC NEWS BBC News, 11:04 PM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT Russia after meeting Z. Zelensky. BBC NEWS Oslo, 20 October BBC News, 11:05 PM ET: Zelensky calls for trilateral talks with US and Russia BBC News, 11:06 PM ET: Zelensky calls for trilateral talks with US and Russia CNN, 12:01 AM ET: WITKOFF HEADS TO RUSSIA BBC News, 12:03 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 12:05 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 12:06 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 12:07 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 12:08 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky CNN, 12:30 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 12:31 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 12:39 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 12:39 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 12:40 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 12:41 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY BBC News, 1:03 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 1:05 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 1:06 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 1:07 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky CNN, 1:12 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 1:13 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY BBC News, 2:14 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 2:15 AM ET: Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 3:11 AM ET: Witkoff in Russia for meeting with Putin BBC News, 4:12 AM ET: Witkoff in Russia for meeting with Putin Fox News, 4:28 AM ET: WITKOFF IN RUSSIA AFTER TALKS WITH ZELENSKYY Fox News, 4:28 AM ET: SPECIAL ENVOY WITKOFF IN RUSSIA FOR PEACE TALKS BBC News, 5:12 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 5:14 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 5:15 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin Fox News, 5:23 AM ET: SPECIAL ENVOY WITKOFF HOLDS PEACE TALKS W/ PUTIN CNN, 5:23 AM ET: "Progress" In Talks With Zelensky CNN, 5:24 AM ET: WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 5:24 AM ET: "Progress" In Talks With Zelensky Fox News, 5:24 AM ET: SPECIAL ENVOY WITKOFF HOLDS PEACE TALKS W/ PUTIN BBC News, 5:42 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 5:55 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin Fox News, 6:01 AM ET: SPECIAL ENVOY WITKOFF HOLDS PEACE TALKS W/ PUTIN BBC News, 6:15 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 6:16 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 6:45 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 6:46 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 6:47 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 6:49 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 10:00 AM ET: Ukraine war talks BBC News, 10:15 AM ET: Reports Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks BBC News, 10:17 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 10:19 AM ET: Witkoff urges resumption of three way talks MSNOW, 10:31 AM ET: WITKOFF ON RUBBARD RELEASE: PUTIN IS A "HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 11:15 AM ET: Reports Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks BBC News, 11:17 AM ET: Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks BBC News, 11:19 AM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 1:17 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 1:22 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 2:01 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 2:04 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 2:05 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin CNN, 2:08 PM ET: RUSSIA WILLING TO RESUME TRILATERAL PEACE TALKS BBC News, 2:07 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 2:09 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin CNN, 2:20 PM ET: WITKOFF LEAVES RUSSIA AFTER THREE-HOUR MEETING WITH PUTIN CNN, 2:25 PM ET: RUSSIA WILLING TO RESUME TRILATERAL PEACE TALKS CNN, 2:26 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 2:26 PM ET: RUSSIA WILLING TO RESUME TALKS WITH UKRAINE & U.S. NEXT MONTH CNN, 2:26 PM ET: RUSSIA WILLING TO RESUME TALKS WITH UKRAINE & U.S. NEXT MONTH CNN, 2:27 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 2:27 PM ET: WITKOFF CALLS PUTIN "A HUMANITARIAN" AS WAR ON UKRAINE RAGES CNN, 2:28 PM ET: WITKOFF CALLS PUTIN "A HUMANITARIAN" AS WAR ON UKRAINE RAGES MSNOW, 3:02 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:01 PM ET: Ukraine war talks MSNOW, 3:03 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:03 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:02 PM ET: Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks MSNOW, 3:04 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:04 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:03 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 3:03 PM ET: Witkoff urges resumption of three way talks MSNOW, 3:05 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:05 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:04 PM ET: Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks BBC News, 3:04 PM ET: Witkoff urges resumption of three way talks MSNOW, 3:06 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:05 PM ET: Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks MSNOW, 3:07 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:07 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:07 PM ET: Kremlin 'ready' to resume US-Russia-Ukraine talks BBC News, 3:07 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' BBC News, 3:08 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' BBC News, 3:08 PM ET: Zelensky 'favourable' for trilateral meeting as soon as possible BBC News, 3:09 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' MSNOW, 3:11 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:11 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:10 PM ET: Zelensky 'spoke with US envoy' after Putin-Witkoff meeting BBC News, 3:10 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' MSNOW, 3:12 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:11 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' MSNOW, 3:13 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:13 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' BBC News, 3:13 PM ET: Zelensky: In favour of US-Ukraine-Russia meeting MSNOW, 3:16 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:16 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:16 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 3:15 PM ET: Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' MSNOW, 3:17 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:17 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 3:17 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" Fox News, 3:18 PM ET: TRUMP NEGOTIATING WITH RUSSIA TO END UKRAINE WAR Fox News, 3:19 PM ET: TRUMP GETTING CLOSE TO SETTLING UKRAINE WAR Fox News, 3:19 PM ET: TRUMP NEGOTIATING WITH RUSSIA TO END UKRAINE WAR BBC News, 3:27 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 3:33 PM ET: Ukraine war talks CNN, 3:36 PM ET: U.S. ENVOY WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN IN EFFORT TO END WAR IN UKRAINE CNN, 3:38 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 3:38 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 3:38 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 3:39 PM ET: WITKOFF CALLS PUTIN "A HUMANITARIAN" AS WAR ON UKRAINE RAGES CNN, 3:39 PM ET: WITKOFF CALLS PUTIN "A HUMANITARIAN" AS WAR ON UKRAINE RAGES CNN, 3:39 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 3:39 PM ET: WITKOFF MEETS PUTIN ONE DAY AFTER MEETING ZELENSKY CNN, 3:40 PM ET: WITKOFF CALLS PUTIN "A HUMANITARIAN" AS WAR ON UKRAINE RAGES CNN, 3:40 PM ET: WITKOFF CALLS PUTIN "A HUMANITARIAN" AS WAR ON UKRAINE RAGES MSNOW, 4:01 PM ET: WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:02 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:04 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:04 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:05 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:05 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:06 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:07 PM ET: WITKOFF TO PUTIN: "YOU ARE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:12 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:14 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:14 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:16 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:16 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:20 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 4:19 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin MSNOW, 4:21 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 4:21 PM ET: TRUMP DEFENDS WITKOFF CALLING PUTIN A "HUMANITARIAN" BBC News, 4:20 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 4:21 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 4:22 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 5:01 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 5:02 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 5:03 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 5:04 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 5:05 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 5:06 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 5:08 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff says Putin a 'humanitarian' BBC News, 5:10 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff says Putin a 'humanitarian' BBC News, 5:11 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff says Putin a 'humanitarian' BBC News, 5:12 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff says Putin a 'humanitarian' BBC News, 5:12 PM ET: US envoy Witkoff says Putin a 'humanitarian' CNN, 5:37 PM ET: GOP SENS OUTRAGED AFTER WITKOFF PRAISES "HUMANITARIAN" PUTIN CNN, 5:38 PM ET: GOP SENS OUTRAGED AFTER WITKOFF PRAISES "HUMANITARIAN" PUTIN CNN, 5:38 PM ET: GOP sent outraged after Witkoff praises "humanitarian" Putin. Steve Witkoff | U.S. Special Envoy Fox News, 6:02 PM ET: CEASEFIRE. ZELENSKYY SAYS HE WOULD ACCEPT PEACE DEAL TO FREEZE WAR BBC News, 6:02 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 6:03 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 6:04 PM ET: Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US 📻 radio NPR News Now, Oct 21, 3:10 PM ET: story 5 of 7 ABC News Update, Oct 21, 1:32 PM ET: story 3 of 4 ABC News Update, Oct 21, 11:32 AM ET: story 3 of 4 NPR News Now, Oct 21, 11:10 AM ET: the lead NPR News Now, Oct 21, 10:10 AM ET: story 3 of 7 ABC News Update, Oct 21, 6:32 AM ET: story 2 of 5 NPR News Now, Oct 21, 6:10 AM ET: the lead NPR News Now, Oct 21, 5:09 AM ET: the lead
Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline
from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not
rated); a dot marks a new headline. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it
(bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details.
📡 wire copy: 4 outlets ran the AP, Reuters headline nearly word for word (Independent Journal Review, Military.com, Newsmax, Star Tribune)
📌 linked by aggregators: Political Wire Drudge Report Google News
💬 quoted: “humanitarian” 5 “Ready” 3 “fully satisfied” “in principle” “Ready To Resume” 2 “has been fine on Ukraine” “FOX & Friends” “Denuclearization”
✏️ 23 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
AP (3 wordings): “Trump envoy Witkoff meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine war talks” → “Russia agrees to resume three-way talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says”Axios (2 wordings): “Witkoff asks Putin to resume direct peace talks, Russia releases U.S. detainee” → “Putin tells Witkoff he is ready to resume direct peace talks, Russia releases U.S. detainee”BBC (5 wordings): “US envoy to meet Putin in Russia as Zelensky says intelligence sharing 'works now'” → “Russia says it is ready to resume talks with Ukraine and US to end war”Bloomberg (4 wordings): “Putin Meets US Envoy Witkoff to Discuss Ukraine Peace Proposals” → “Putin Releases Hostage to US, Earning Praise as Humanitarian”CNN (2 wordings): “Breaking News US envoy Witkoff lands in Russia for talks with Putin” → “US envoy Witkoff meets with Putin in effort to advance proposals to end war in Ukraine”Financial Times (2 wordings): “Witkoff meets Zelenskyy before travelling to Russia” → “Trump envoy floats Ukraine talks and summit with Putin and Xi”Foreign Policy (2 wordings): “The U.S. Is Pushing for Ukraine Peace Talks. Is Putin Interested?” → “Witkoff Pushes Putin to Restart Peace Talks”Fox News (3 wordings): “Ukraine's Zelenskyy describes potential path to ceasefire in war with Russia” → “Zelenskyy tells 'FOX & Friends' what he's willing to accept for ceasefire with Russia”HuffPost (4 wordings): “Trump Says Russia's Been 'Fine On Ukraine' As He Rips Zelenskyy” → “Trump’s Ukraine Envoy Faces Backlash For Calling Putin ‘A Humanitarian’”Mediaite (2 wordings): “JUST IN: Vladimir Putin Agrees to Restart Peace Talks With Ukraine, U.S.” → “Vance Downplays Criticism of Witkoff’s ‘Humanitarian’ Putin Praise: ‘We Should All Be Celebrating’”Military.com (2 wordings): “Trump Envoy Witkoff Meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine War Talks” → “Putin Agrees to Resume Three-Way Talks on Ukraine War With Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin Says”New York Post (6 wordings): “Trump again blows up on Zelensky, insists Russia ‘has been fine on Ukraine’” → “Putin agrees to trilateral talks with Ukraine, US to end war — with a catch”News Nation (3 wordings): “Russia releases imprisoned American man, US envoy Witkoff says on visit to St. Petersburg” → “Trump special envoy Steve Witkoff praises Putin as 'humanitarian'”Newsmax (7 wordings): “Envoy to Offer Putin Direct Talks With Trump, Zelenskyy” → “Russia 'Ready' to Resume Trilateral Talks, but Cool on Ukraine Deal Chances”Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty (4 wordings): “After Oslo Talks, Zelenskyy Thanks US As Missile Intelligence 'Works Now'” → “After Witkoff Meeting, Putin 'Ready To Resume' US-Led Peace Talks With Ukraine”Red State (3 wordings): “This May Be It: Putin Agrees to Peace Talks, Zelensky Open to Deal That Freezes Lines Nick Arama” → “Ukraine This May Be It: Putin Agrees to Peace Talks, Zelensky Open to Deal That Freezes Lines Nick Arama”Reuters (7 wordings): “US envoy Witkoff to meet Putin, Trump presses Kyiv to settle” → “Putin agrees to resume 3-way peace talks with Ukraine and US - Reuters”The Daily Wire (2 wordings): “Putin Agrees To Three-Way Peace Talks After Meeting With Trump Envoys” → “Putin Agrees To Three-Way Ukraine Peace Talks After Meeting With Trump Envoys”The Guardian (2 wordings): “US has resumed sharing intelligence with Ukraine about Russian strikes, says Zelenskyy” → “Putin orders release of jailed American as he meets Trump envoy for Ukraine talks”The Hill (2 wordings): “Witkoff, Kushner to meet with Zelensky” → “Zelensky says he’d be open to freezing front lines to end Russia war”The Independent (2 wordings): “Trump's envoy says he hopes to restart three-way talks with Russia and Ukraine” → “Trump’s special envoy tells Putin he is a ‘humanitarian’”The Sun (3 wordings): “DON’S DEAL Trump’s envoy to meet Putin with new plan to end war as president warns Zelensky” → “TRUCE HOPES Putin 'ready' to resume talks with US & Ukraine IN WEEKS after 3hr showdown”Yahoo News (2 wordings): “Trump says Russia 'has been fine on Ukraine' as he makes deals with Putin” → “Putin agrees to new Ukraine peace talks as Trump turns up pressure on Zelensky”
Every outlet's first headline (43), left to right by AllSides rating
HuffPost
Trump Says Russia's Been 'Fine On Ukraine' As He Rips Zelenskyy Oct 19, 9 PM ET
The Guardian
US has resumed sharing intelligence with Ukraine about Russian strikes, says Zelenskyy Oct 20, 4 PM ET
ABC News
Witkoff arrives in St. Petersburg for Putin talks, Kremlin aide says Oct 21, 5 AM ET
AP
Trump envoy Witkoff meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine war talks Oct 21, 7 AM ET
Axios
Witkoff asks Putin to resume direct peace talks, Russia releases U.S. detainee Oct 21, 8 AM ET
CBS News
Witkoff says he hopes Ukraine included in U.S., Russia talks Oct 21, 9 AM ET
CNBC
Witkoff calls Putin a 'humanitarian' at Russia peace talks without Ukraine Oct 21, 10 AM ET
CNN
Breaking News US envoy Witkoff lands in Russia for talks with Putin Oct 21, 4 AM ET
Mediaite
JUST IN: Vladimir Putin Agrees to Restart Peace Talks With Ukraine, U.S. Oct 21, 11 AM ET
Military.com
Trump Envoy Witkoff Meets Putin in St. Petersburg for Ukraine War Talks Oct 21, 10 AM ET
NBC News
Kremlin says it’s ready to resume trilateral peace talks Oct 21, 5 PM ET
New York Times
An American Teacher Went to Ukraine. Now He’s in a Russian Prison. Oct 21, 6 AM ET
PBS NewsHour
Putin agrees to resume trilateral Russia-Ukraine-U.S. talks next month Oct 21, 11 AM ET
Semafor
US envoy Steve Witkoff holds talks with Putin Oct 21, 8 AM ET
S Star Tribune
Putin agrees to resume three-way talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says Oct 21, 2 PM ET
The Independent
Trump's envoy says he hopes to restart three-way talks with Russia and Ukraine Oct 21, 8 AM ET
W The Week
Morning Report Trump says Russia ‘has been fine on Ukraine’ Oct 20, 6 PM ET
Time
Trump Open to ‘Denuclearization’ Summit with Putin and Xi Oct 20, 10 AM ET
Yahoo News
Trump says Russia 'has been fine on Ukraine' as he makes deals with Putin Oct 20, 6 PM ET
BBC
US envoy to meet Putin in Russia as Zelensky says intelligence sharing 'works now' Oct 21, 1 AM ET
Bloomberg
Putin Meets US Envoy Witkoff to Discuss Ukraine Peace Proposals Oct 21, 8 AM ET
Chicago Tribune
Russia President Vladimir Putin agrees to resume trilateral talks on Ukraine war, Kremlin says Oct 21, 11 AM ET
F Financial Times
Witkoff meets Zelenskyy before travelling to Russia Oct 20, 12 PM ET
Foreign Policy
The U.S. Is Pushing for Ukraine Peace Talks. Is Putin Interested? Oct 21, 4 PM ET
Fortune
Putin agrees ‘in principle’ to resume talks with Washington and Kyiv to end war in Ukraine—but still isn’t ‘fully satisfied’ with proposals Oct 21, 5 PM ET
News Nation
Russia releases imprisoned American man, US envoy Witkoff says on visit to St. Petersburg Oct 21, 6 AM ET
Reuters
US envoy Witkoff to meet Putin, Trump presses Kyiv to settle Oct 20, 7 PM ET
Scripps News
Russia Putin agrees to resume Ukraine peace talks after meeting with Trump envoy AP via Scripps News Group Oct 21, 11 AM ET
The Hill
Witkoff, Kushner to meet with Zelensky Oct 20, 1 PM ET
WSJ
Trump Says He’s Open to Talks With the Leaders of Russia and China Oct 19, 6 PM ET
Just the News
Putin agrees to resume talks with U.S., Ukraine Oct 21, 11 AM ET
The Epoch Times
Witkoff, Putin Meet for Talks on Ukraine in St. Petersburg Oct 21, 1 PM ET
The Sun
DON’S DEAL Trump’s envoy to meet Putin with new plan to end war as president warns Zelensky Oct 21, 6 AM ET
The Washington Times
Trump open to Putin, Xi summit on ending Ukraine war without Zelenskyy Oct 19, 7 PM ET
Washington Examiner
Zelensky says he would accept peace deal freezing war along current lines Oct 21, 1 PM ET
Breitbart
Zelensky Says He Would Accept Deal to Freeze Ukraine War at Current Lines Oct 21, 8 PM ET
Fox News
Ukraine's Zelenskyy describes potential path to ceasefire in war with Russia Oct 21, 11 AM ET
IJR
Witkoff Arrives in St. Petersburg for Putin Talks Oct 21, 7 AM ET
New York Post
Trump again blows up on Zelensky, insists Russia ‘has been fine on Ukraine’ Oct 19, 7 PM ET
Newsmax
Envoy to Offer Putin Direct Talks With Trump, Zelenskyy Oct 20, 4 PM ET
Red State
This May Be It: Putin Agrees to Peace Talks, Zelensky Open to Deal That Freezes Lines Nick Arama Oct 21, 11 AM ET
The Daily Wire
Putin Agrees To Three-Way Peace Talks After Meeting With Trump Envoys Oct 21, 2 PM ET
RFE/RL
After Oslo Talks, Zelenskyy Thanks US As Missile Intelligence 'Works Now' Oct 20, 4 PM ET
📡 Broadcast
TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it
BBC News 47 min
CNN 15 min
MSNOW 9 min
Fox News 4 min
US envoy Witkoff meets President Putin BBC News, 9 min Russia and Ukraine open to three-way talks with US BBC News, 7 min WITKROFF TO PUTIN: "YOU'RE A HUMANITARIAN" MSNOW, 5 min Zelensky hopes for meeting 'no later than November' BBC News, 5 min Witkoff to visit Russia after meeting Zelensky BBC News, 5 min US envoy Witkoff meets with President Putin BBC News, 4 min WITKOFF TO VISIT RUSSIA AFTER "PROGRESS" IN TALKS WITH ZELENSKY CNN, 4 min US envoy Witkoff says Putin a 'humanitarian' BBC News, 3 min
NPR News Now , Oct 21, 3:10 PM ET: story 5 of 7ABC News Update , Oct 21, 1:32 PM ET: story 3 of 4ABC News Update , Oct 21, 11:32 AM ET: story 3 of 4NPR News Now , Oct 21, 11:10 AM ET: the leadNPR News Now , Oct 21, 10:10 AM ET: story 3 of 7ABC News Update , Oct 21, 6:32 AM ET: story 2 of 5NPR News Now , Oct 21, 6:10 AM ET: the leadNPR News Now , Oct 21, 5:09 AM ET: the lead
🧶 Retelling
what people online made of it
🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.
🗣️ names in it: Russia Ukraine Donald Trump Volodymyr Zelenskyy Putin
🔎 Checking
what the fact-checkers looked into
🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.