🗞️ Story file #617
Ukraine says US intelligence sharing resumes after pause
Oct 18, 7 PM ET to Oct 20, 8 PM ET · 1 outlet not rated for lean
📰 11 outlets carried it ⚖️ 🫏2 · 5 · 3🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 2 days on the front pages 📈 7 front pages at once, at its peak 📺 26 min of TV captions 🧵 1 of 2 parts of a saga
👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through
TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is
part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say
how each is made.
📰 Spread the front pages that ran it, hour by hour
Oct 19 12 PM Oct 20 12 PM 4 8 left center right not rated Front pages carrying it at each hourly run, Oct 18, 7 PM to Oct 20, 8 PM ET (peak 8), by the outlets' lean:
Oct 18, 12 PM Oct 19 12 PM Oct 20 12 PM BloombergBloomberg Bloomberg, Oct 18, 7:00 AM ET: Zelenskyy Says Intelligence Sharing With US Working Again New York PostNew York Post New York Post, Oct 18, 10:00 AM ET: Zelensky reveals US intel sharing is back after blackout left Ukraine blind to Russian attacks New York Post, Oct 18, 12:00 PM ET: Back online Zelensky reveals US intel sharing is back after blackout left Ukraine blind to Russian attacks New York Post, Oct 18, 12:00 PM ET: Zelensky expressed gratitude that the lull in intelligence sharing, which lasted about three days and undermined Ukraine’s ability to prepare for the attacks, has since ended. NewsmaxNewsmax Newsmax, Oct 18, 11:00 AM ET: Zelenskyy: US Resumes Intelligence-Sharing With Ukraine ReutersReuters Reuters, Oct 18, 11:00 AM ET: US resumes intelligence-sharing with Ukraine after pause, Zelenskiy says The GuardianThe Guardian The Guardian, Oct 18, 1:00 PM ET: Zelenskyy thanks Trump for resumed intelligence sharing after US Starlink ‘message’ The Guardian, Oct 20, 4:00 PM ET: US has resumed sharing intelligence with Ukraine about Russian strikes, says Zelenskyy HuffPostHuffPost HuffPost, Oct 18, 7:00 PM ET: U.S. Resumes Intelligence-sharing With Ukraine After Pause, Zelenskyy Says The Epoch TimesThe Epoch Times The Epoch Times, Oct 18, 9:00 PM ET: US Intelligence Sharing Resumes After Pause, Zelenskyy Says NewsweekNewsweek Newsweek, Oct 19, 11:00 AM ET: US Contradicts Zelensky On Intelligence Sharing Claim The HillThe Hill The Hill, Oct 19, 5:00 PM ET: Zelensky disputes US resumed intelligence sharing with Ukraine BBCBBC BBC, Oct 20, 4:00 PM ET: Zelensky says US intelligence sharing 'works now' after talks with Trump envoy in Oslo RFE/RLRadio Free Europe Radio Liberty Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, Oct 20, 4:00 PM ET: After Oslo Talks, Zelenskyy Thanks US As Missile Intelligence 'Works Now' 📺 TV CNN, 9:43 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:43 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:46 PM ET: TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:39 AM ET: ZELENSKY TALKS WITH RUBIO AS RIFT WITH TRUMP WIDENS CNN, 7:42 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:42 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:43 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:44 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:44 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:45 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7:45 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 8:25 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 8:26 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 9:32 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE BBC News, 4:07 PM ET: Zelensky: Intelligence sharing on strikes 'works now' BBC News, 4:08 PM ET: Zelensky: Intelligence sharing on strikes 'works now' BBC News, 5:02 PM ET: Zelensky: US now providing early-warning intelligence BBC News, 5:04 PM ET: Zelensky: US now providing early-warning intelligence BBC News, 5:08 PM ET: Zelensky: US now providing early-warning intelligence CNN, 5:32 PM ET: ZELENSKY: “INTELLIGENCE SHARING WORKS NOW” CNN, 5:33 PM ET: ZELENSKY: “INTELLIGENCE SHARING WORKS NOW” BBC News, 6:02 PM ET: Zelensky: Ukraine united with European allies BBC News, 6:03 PM ET: Zelensky: US now providing early-warning intelligence BBC News, 9:08 PM ET: ZELENSKY Says He Has Spoken to US envoys BBC News, 9:10 PM ET: ZELENSKY Says He Has Spoken to US envoys BBC News, 12:13 AM ET: US resumes sharing intelligence with Ukraine BBC News, 12:14 AM ET: US resumes sharing intelligence with Ukraine BBC News, 1:12 AM ET: Zelensky speaks to US envoys to try to ease tensions BBC News, 1:13 AM ET: Zelensky speaks to US envoys to try to ease tensions CNN, 2:11 AM ET: ZELENSKY: U.S. SIDING WITH RUSSIA WOULD BE "HISTORIC MISTAKE" CNN, 2:11 AM ET: ZELENSKY: U.S. SIDING WITH RUSSIA WOULD BE "HISTORIC MISTAKE" CNN, 2:12 AM ET: ZELENSKY: U.S. SIDING WITH RUSSIA WOULD BE "HISTORIC MISTAKE" BBC News, 10:07 AM ET: Rubio denies intelligence sharing pause Fox News, 10:10 AM ET: ZELENSKYY CLAIMS U.S. BRIEFLY HALTED WAR INTEL MSNOW, 11:04 AM ET: RUBIO DENIES U.S. PAUSED INTEL SHARING WITH UKRAINE BBC News, 2:14 PM ET: Zelensky adviser: Intelligence of only one missile BBC News, 2:15 PM ET: Zelensky adviser: Intelligence of only one missile BBC News, 2:17 PM ET: Zelensky adviser: Intelligence of only one missile BBC News, 2:18 PM ET: Zelensky adviser: Intelligence of only one missile BBC News, 2:19 PM ET: Zelensky adviser: Intelligence of only one missile Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline
from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not
rated); a dot marks a new headline. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it
(bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details.
📌 linked by aggregators: Google News
💬 quoted: “works now” 2 “message”
✏️ 2 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
New York Post (3 wordings): “Zelensky reveals US intel sharing is back after blackout left Ukraine blind to Russian attacks” → “Zelensky expressed gratitude that the lull in intelligence sharing, which lasted about three days and undermined Ukraine’s ability to prepare for the attacks, has since ended.”The Guardian (2 wordings): “Zelenskyy thanks Trump for resumed intelligence sharing after US Starlink ‘message’” → “US has resumed sharing intelligence with Ukraine about Russian strikes, says Zelenskyy”Every outlet's first headline (11), left to right by AllSides rating
U.S. Resumes Intelligence-sharing With Ukraine After Pause, Zelenskyy Says Oct 18, 7 PM ET Zelenskyy thanks Trump for resumed intelligence sharing after US Starlink ‘message’ Oct 18, 1 PM ET Zelensky says US intelligence sharing 'works now' after talks with Trump envoy in Oslo Oct 20, 4 PM ET Zelenskyy Says Intelligence Sharing With US Working Again Oct 18, 7 AM ET US Contradicts Zelensky On Intelligence Sharing Claim Oct 19, 11 AM ET US resumes intelligence-sharing with Ukraine after pause, Zelenskiy says Oct 18, 11 AM ET Zelensky disputes US resumed intelligence sharing with Ukraine Oct 19, 5 PM ET US Intelligence Sharing Resumes After Pause, Zelenskyy Says Oct 18, 9 PM ET Zelensky reveals US intel sharing is back after blackout left Ukraine blind to Russian attacks Oct 18, 10 AM ET Zelenskyy: US Resumes Intelligence-Sharing With Ukraine Oct 18, 11 AM ET After Oslo Talks, Zelenskyy Thanks US As Missile Intelligence 'Works Now' Oct 20, 4 PM ET
📡 Broadcast TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it
CNN 16 min
BBC News 9 min
Fox News 28 s
MSNOW 7 s
TRUMP DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTEL WITH UKRAINE CNN, 7 min RUBIO DENIES U.S. STOPPED SHARING INTELLIGENCE WITH UKRAINE CNN, 6 min Zelensky adviser: Intelligence of only one missile BBC News, 2 min Zelensky: US now providing early-warning intelligence BBC News, 2 min ZELENSKY: U.S. SIDING WITH RUSSIA WOULD BE "HISTORIC MISTAKE" CNN, 2 min Zelensky: Intelligence sharing on strikes 'works now' BBC News, 78 s Zelensky speaks to US envoys to try to ease tensions BBC News, 64 s ZELENSKY: “INTELLIGENCE SHARING WORKS NOW” CNN, 63 s
🧶 Retelling what people online made of it
🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.
🗣️ names in it: Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyy Russia
🔎 Checking what the fact-checkers looked into
🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.
🧵 Persistence the running story it belongs to
Ukraine says US intelligence sharing resumes after pause (this story)
Oct 18, 7 PM ET
Rubio tells Zelensky U.S. not deliberately denying Ukraine intelligence or weapons
Oct 20, 12 PM ET
HuffPost
U.S. Resumes Intelligence-sharing With Ukraine After Pause, Zelenskyy Says Oct 18, 7 PM ET
The Guardian
Zelenskyy thanks Trump for resumed intelligence sharing after US Starlink ‘message’ Oct 18, 1 PM ET
BBC
Zelensky says US intelligence sharing 'works now' after talks with Trump envoy in Oslo Oct 20, 4 PM ET
Bloomberg
Zelenskyy Says Intelligence Sharing With US Working Again Oct 18, 7 AM ET
Newsweek
US Contradicts Zelensky On Intelligence Sharing Claim Oct 19, 11 AM ET
Reuters
US resumes intelligence-sharing with Ukraine after pause, Zelenskiy says Oct 18, 11 AM ET
The Hill
Zelensky disputes US resumed intelligence sharing with Ukraine Oct 19, 5 PM ET
The Epoch Times
US Intelligence Sharing Resumes After Pause, Zelenskyy Says Oct 18, 9 PM ET
New York Post
Zelensky reveals US intel sharing is back after blackout left Ukraine blind to Russian attacks Oct 18, 10 AM ET
Newsmax
Zelenskyy: US Resumes Intelligence-Sharing With Ukraine Oct 18, 11 AM ET
RFE/RL
After Oslo Talks, Zelenskyy Thanks US As Missile Intelligence 'Works Now' Oct 20, 4 PM ET