← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #58

Trump and Gruden attend Ohio rally supporting GOP Senate candidate

Oct 4, 1 PM ET to Oct 6, 7 PM ET

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 4, 2 PM ETfirst on a front page: One America News Network
  2. Oct 4, 2 PM ETfirst on the radio: ABC News Update
  3. Oct 4, 7 PM ETpeak: on 22 front pages
  4. Oct 4, 9 PM ETfirst on TV: Fox News
  5. Oct 5, 8 AM ETretold online by 7 people

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

Oct 512 PMOct 612 PM1020leftcenterright
Front pages carrying it at each hourly run, Oct 4, 1 PM to Oct 6, 7 PM ET (peak 20), by the outlets' lean: left · center · right
Oct 412 PMOct 512 PMOct 612 PMPBS NewsHourPBS NewsHourPBS NewsHour, Oct 3, 5:00 PM ET: Trump rallies in Ohio to boost Jon Husted in a tight Senate race against Sherrod BrownWashington ExaminerWashington ExaminerWashington Examiner, Oct 3, 5:00 PM ET: WATCH LIVE: Trump holds a rally in Vandalia, OhioChicago TribuneChicago TribuneChicago Tribune, Oct 3, 7:00 PM ET: Pres. Donald Trump rallies in Ohio to boost Jon Husted in a tight Senate race against Sherrod BrownThe Gateway PunditThe Gateway PunditThe Gateway Pundit, Oct 3, 8:00 PM ET: WATCH LIVE: President Trump Delivers Remarks at Rally for Husted and Ramaswamy in Dayton, OhioThe Gateway Pundit, Oct 4, 4:00 PM ET: WATCH: Trump Tells Ohio Crowd, “We’re Going to Win Big and We’re Going to Shove it Up Their Ass” While Pointing at the Fake NewsNewsweekNewsweekNewsweek, Oct 3, 10:00 PM ET: Trump Uses Crude Remark While Predicting Ohio GOP Ticket WinsNewsweek, Oct 6, 2:00 PM ET: Donald Trump Teases ‘Midterm Surprise’: History of October Election ShocksBloombergBloombergBloomberg, Oct 3, 10:00 PM ET: Trump Pitches Company Investment to Ohio Voters at Midterm RallyThe Epoch TimesThe Epoch TimesThe Epoch Times, Oct 3, 10:00 PM ET: Trump Participates in Rally in Vandalia, OhioThe Epoch Times, Oct 4, 12:00 PM ET: Trump Urges Ohioans to Pass Voter ID Issue, Support GOP CandidatesReutersReutersReuters, Oct 3, 11:01 PM ET: Trump tries to fire up Ohio voters as Republicans defend Senate seat in close raceHuffPostHuffPostHuffPost, Oct 4, 12:01 AM ET: Trump Tries To Fire Up Ohio Voters: 'We're Going To Win Big And We're Going To Shove It Up Their Ass'HuffPost, Oct 6, 11:00 AM ET: Defiant Trump Predicts Midterms ‘Surprise’New York PostNew York PostNew York Post, Oct 4, 12:01 AM ET: Trump defends data centers in Ohio, warns they’ll go to China if US turns them awayNewsmaxNewsmaxNewsmax, Oct 4, 6:01 AM ET: Trump Defends Data Centers at Ohio RallyNewsmax, Oct 4, 7:01 AM ET: Trump Defends Data Centers at Rousing Ohio RallyFox NewsFox NewsFox News, Oct 4, 8:00 AM ET: Trump tells Ohio crowd that midterm polls 'don't account for one thing'The GuardianThe GuardianThe Guardian, Oct 4, 8:00 AM ET: Trump sets off on midterm blitz – are his trademark rallies a liability for Republicans?Scripps NewsScripps NewsScripps News, Oct 4, 10:00 AM ET: Politics Trump rallies in Ohio during 32-day midterm tour as Senate race tightens Haley BullThe HillThe HillThe Hill, Oct 4, 10:00 AM ET: Trump backs data centers in Ohio amid tight Senate raceThe Hill, Oct 5, 2:00 PM ET: Trump to campaign with Husted in OhioYahoo NewsYahoo NewsYahoo News, Oct 4, 11:00 AM ET: Trump, campaigning in Ohio, says the midterms will bring a ‘big surprise’Yahoo News, Oct 5, 10:00 AM ET: Trump takes extraordinary steps to target midterms, alarming criticsOANOne America News NetworkOne America News Network, Oct 4, 2:00 PM ET: Trump bashes ‘communists, socialists, radicalized lunatics and villains’ in Ohio rally supporting GOP candidatesOne America News Network, Oct 6, 1:00 PM ET: ‘MY RALLIES ARE SAVING THE REPUBLICAN PARTY’: Trump touts rallies, tells supporters to witness the ‘Midterm Surprise’FortuneFortuneFortune, Oct 4, 4:00 PM ET: Trump’s Ohio rally gets quiet after he defends data centers — a toxic political issue with bipartisan opposition. ‘You can’t just turn them off’APAPAP, Oct 4, 5:00 PM ET: Trump defends data centers in Ohio as he rallies to boost Jon Husted in a tight Senate race - apnews.comThe IndependentThe IndependentThe Independent, Oct 4, 7:00 PM ET: Trump says data centers are the future — deal with itMediaiteMediaiteMediaite, Oct 6, 10:00 AM ET: Trump Touts ‘Unbelievable’ Rally Crowds, Promises ‘Midterm Surprise’: ‘The Dumocrats Never Counted on This’Mediaite, Oct 6, 5:00 PM ET: Trump Hints at ‘Some Big Surprises’ Coming In a ‘Few Weeks’ Before the Midterm ElectionJust the NewsJust the NewsJust the News, Oct 6, 10:00 AM ET: Trump predicts 'midterm surprise' as he touts rally crowdsUSA TodayUSA TodayUSA Today, Oct 6, 11:00 AM ET: Trump takes extraordinary steps to target midterm elections, alarming criticsRaw StoryRaw StoryRaw Story, Oct 6, 11:00 AM ET: Trump teases major ‘midterm surprise’ in cryptic announcement: ‘It’s all happening!’The Daily SignalThe Daily SignalThe Daily Signal, Oct 6, 1:00 PM ET: Donald Trump, Ohio Republicans Rile Up Crowd One Month Before Election Day📺 TVMSNOW, 11:02 PM ET: VITAL SENATE RACEMSNOW, 2:12 AM ET: NEBRASKA INDEPENDENT DAN OSBORN RUNNING INFox News, 4:22 AM ET: CELEBRITIES RAIL AGAINST TRUMP AT VOTING RALLYMSNOW, 4:54 AM ET: PROTESTERS RALLY OUTSIDE OF TRUMP'S OKLAHOMA RALLYCNN, 5:32 AM ET: JD Vance Joins Dan Sullivan In Alaska. As GOP Fights To Hold Tight Senate SeatCNN, 9:03 AM ET: TRUMP & VANCE HIT THE TRAIL TO RALLY SUPPORT IN GOP STRONGHOLDSCNN, 9:03 AM ET: TRUMP & VANCE HIT THE TRAIL TO RALLY SUPPORT IN GOP STRONGHOLDSCNN, 9:04 AM ET: TRUMP & VANCE HIT THE TRAIL TO RALLY SUPPORT IN GOP STRONGHOLDSMSNOW, 9:05 AM ET: TRUMP RALLIES IN NEBRASKA TO TRY TO LIFT GOP INCUMBENTSFox News, 10:07 AM ET: TRUMP TO VISIT TX AS DEMS PUSH TO FLIP SENATE SEATFox News, 10:08 AM ET: TRUMP TO VISIT TX AS DEMS PUSH TO FLIP SENATE SEATFox News, 10:34 AM ET: HIGH-STAKES NE SENATE RACE TAKES CENTER STAGEFox News, 11:01 AM ET: TRUMP RALLIES IN NE TO BOOST GOP SEN RICKETTSMSNOW, 1:12 PM ET: TRUMP WELCOMES NATALIE HARP ON RALLY STAGEMSNOW, 1:12 PM ET: TRUMP WELCOMES NATALIE HARP ON RALLY STAGEMSNOW, 1:13 PM ET: TRUMP WELCOMES NATALIE HARP ON RALLY STAGEFox News, 3:26 PM ET: NOW: MICHIGAN GOP SENATE CANDIDATE MIKE ROGERSFox News, 3:27 PM ET: NOW: MICHIGAN GOP SENATE CANDIDATE MIKE ROGERSMSNOW, 5:05 PM ET: DODGES ON TRUMP MEETING WITH CONVICTED ELECTION DENIERMSNOW, 5:06 PM ET: DODGES ON TRUMP MEETING WITH CONVICTED ELECTION DENIERMSNOW, 5:06 PM ET: DODGES ON TRUMP MEETING WITH CONVICTED ELECTION DENIERMSNOW, 5:07 PM ET: DODGES ON TRUMP MEETING WITH CONVICTED ELECTION DENIERMSNOW, 5:07 PM ET: ELECTION DENIERMSNOW, 5:09 PM ET: DODGES ON TRUMP MEETING WITH CONVICTED ELECTION DENIERFox News, 9:30 PM ET: TRUMP URGES VOTERS TO TRUST REPUBLICAN LEADERSHIPFox News, 9:30 PM ET: TRUMP URGES VOTERS TO TRUST REPUBLICAN LEADERSHIPMSNOW, 10:16 PM ET: DEMOCRAT SHERROD BROWN LOOKS TO WIN BACK OHIOMSNOW, 10:17 PM ET: DEMOCRAT SHERROD BROWN LOOKS TO WIN BACK OHIOMSNOW, 10:20 PM ET: DEMOCRAT SHERROD BROWN LOOKS TO WIN BACK OHIOMSNOW, 10:21 PM ET: DEMOCRAT SHERROD BROWN LOOKS TO WIN BACK OHIOFox News, 12:30 AM ET: TRUMP URGES VOTERS TO TRUST REPUBLICAN LEADERSHIPFox News, 12:30 AM ET: TRUMP HITS CAMPAIGN TRAIL AS ELECTION DAY NEARSFox News, 1:26 AM ET: RACE FOR CONTROL OF THE SENATEFox News, 1:28 AM ET: RACE FOR CONTROL OF THE SENATEFox News, 1:28 AM ET: RACE FOR CONTROL OF THE SENATEFox News, 1:29 AM ET: RACE FOR CONTROL OF THE SENATEFox News, 1:29 AM ET: SENATE RACES TO WATCHFox News, 1:30 AM ET: SENATE RACES TO WATCHFox News, 1:31 AM ET: GOP'S ROAD MAP TO HOLDING THE SENATEFox News, 1:32 AM ET: GOP'S ROAD MAP TO HOLDING THE SENATEFox News, 2:18 AM ET: NEWS | PRESIDENT TRUMP BOOSTS KEY REPUBLICAN CANDIDATES IN OHIO RALLYCNN, 3:47 AM ET: REPUBLICANS SEEK TO SHORE UP SUPPORT FOR IOWA SENATE NOMINEECNN, 3:48 AM ET: REPUBLICANS SEEK TO SHORE UP SUPPORT FOR IOWA SENATE NOMINEECNN, 3:48 AM ET: REPUBLICANS SEEK TO SHORE UP SUPPORT FOR IOWA SENATE NOMINEECNN, 3:50 AM ET: REPUBLICANS SEEK TO SHORE UP SUPPORT FOR IOWA SENATE NOMINEEFox News, 10:20 AM ET: RICKETTS' OPPONENT APOLOGIZES OVER LEAKED AUDIOFox News, 10:22 AM ET: RICKETTS' OPPONENT APOLOGIZES OVER LEAKED AUDIOCNN, 12:16 PM ET: TRUMP HEADS TO NEXT STOP IN RED-STATE RALLY TOUR: NEBRASKACNN, 12:16 PM ET: TRUMP URGES RED-STATE VOTERS: PRETEND I'M RUNNING, GET OUT AND VOTEMSNOW, 12:56 PM ET: TRUMP HEADS TO NEBRASKA FOR CAMPAIGN RALLYMSNOW, 1:05 PM ET: GOP'S RICETTS IN TIGHT RACE IN STATE TRUMP WON BY 20 PTSMSNOW, 1:05 PM ET: GOP'S RICETTS IN TIGHT RACE IN STATE TRUMP WON BY 20 PTSCNN, 2:02 PM ET: TRUMP TO STUMP FOR PAXTON AT TEXAS RALLY THIS WEEKCNN, 2:02 PM ET: TRUMP TO STUMP FOR PAXTON AT TEXAS RALLY THIS WEEKMSNOW, 2:02 PM ET: TRUMP HEADS TO NEBRASKA FOR ANOTHER RED-STATE RALLYCNN, 2:03 PM ET: TRUMP TO STUMP FOR PAXTON AT TEXAS RALLY THIS WEEKMSNOW, 2:07 PM ET: TRUMP HEADS TO NEBRASKA FOR ANOTHER RED-STATE RALLYMSNOW, 2:11 PM ET: TRUMP HEADS TO NEBRASKA FOR ANOTHER RED-STATE RALLYFox News, 3:20 PM ET: FOX POLL: CRUCIAL MI SENATE RACE TIGHT 29 DAYS OUTFox News, 3:57 PM ET: FOX POLL: CRUCIAL MI SENATE RACE TIGHT 29 DAYS OUTFox News, 3:57 PM ET: FOX POLL: CRUCIAL MI SENATE RACE TIGHT 29 DAYS OUTFox News, 3:58 PM ET: FOX POLL: CRUCIAL MI SENATE RACE TIGHT 29 DAYS OUTFox News, 5:01 PM ET: TRUMP BARNSTORMS 5 STATES IN 5 DAYSFox News, 5:02 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:03 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:04 PM ET: TRUMP UNLEASHED. 47 MILES UP GOP BASE WITH MULTI-STATE MIDTERMS BLITZFox News, 5:06 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:07 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:08 PM ET: TRUMP BARNSTORMS 5 STATES IN 5 DAYSFox News, 5:08 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:09 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:10 PM ET: MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANSFox News, 5:10 PM ET: "EVEN IF YOU HATE THEM". TRUMP STRESSES IMPORTANCE OF BACKING GOP IN MIDTERMSFox News, 5:11 PM ET: "EVEN IF YOU HATE THEM". TRUMP STRESSES IMPORTANCE OF BACKING GOP IN MIDTERMSFox News, 5:11 PM ET: TRUMP UNLEASHED. 47 MILES UP GOP BASE WITH MULTI-STATE MIDTERMS BLITZFox News, 5:12 PM ET: TRUMP UNLEASHED. 47 MILES UP GOP BASE WITH MULTI-STATE MIDTERMS BLITZFox News, 5:17 PM ET: RADICAL RAGE FESTS: LIBS HOST ANTI-TRUMP EVENTS IN NYC & DC BEFORE MIDTERMSFox News, 5:19 PM ET: CELEBS TAKE THE STAGE TO BASH TRUMP AT NYC RALLYFox News, 5:21 PM ET: RADICAL RAGE FESTS: LIBS HOST ANTI-TRUMP EVENTS IN NYC & DC BEFORE MIDTERMSFox News, 5:25 PM ET: RADICAL RAGE FESTS: LIBS HOST ANTI-TRUMP EVENTS IN NYC & DC BEFORE MIDTERMS📻 radioABC News Update, Oct 5, 5:32 PM ET: story 2 of 3NPR News Now, Oct 5, 10:10 AM ET: the leadABC News Update, Oct 4, 6:05 PM ET: story 3 of 9ABC News Update, Oct 4, 2:32 PM ET: the lead🧶 online🧶found retold online (the day's report)
Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not rated); a dot marks a new headline. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it (bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details.

📌 linked by aggregators: Political Wire

💬 quoted: “Midterm Surprise” 5 “Few Weeks” “It's all happening!” “MY RALLIES ARE SAVING THE REPUBLICAN PARTY” “The Dumocrats Never Counted on This” “midterm surprise” 4 “Unbelievable”

🗣️ only one side says: 🫏 alarming critics 🫏 trump takes extraordinary steps

✏️ 9 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • HuffPost (2 wordings): “Trump Tries To Fire Up Ohio Voters: 'We're Going To Win Big And We're Going To Shove It Up Their Ass'” → “Defiant Trump Predicts Midterms ‘Surprise’”
  • Mediaite (2 wordings): “Trump Touts ‘Unbelievable’ Rally Crowds, Promises ‘Midterm Surprise’: ‘The Dumocrats Never Counted on This’” → “Trump Hints at ‘Some Big Surprises’ Coming In a ‘Few Weeks’ Before the Midterm Election”
  • Newsmax (2 wordings): “Trump Defends Data Centers at Ohio Rally” → “Trump Defends Data Centers at Rousing Ohio Rally”
  • Newsweek (2 wordings): “Trump Uses Crude Remark While Predicting Ohio GOP Ticket Wins” → “Donald Trump Teases ‘Midterm Surprise’: History of October Election Shocks”
  • One America News Network (2 wordings): “Trump bashes ‘communists, socialists, radicalized lunatics and villains’ in Ohio rally supporting GOP candidates” → “‘MY RALLIES ARE SAVING THE REPUBLICAN PARTY’: Trump touts rallies, tells supporters to witness the ‘Midterm Surprise’”
  • The Epoch Times (2 wordings): “Trump Participates in Rally in Vandalia, Ohio” → “Trump Urges Ohioans to Pass Voter ID Issue, Support GOP Candidates”
  • The Gateway Pundit (2 wordings): “WATCH LIVE: President Trump Delivers Remarks at Rally for Husted and Ramaswamy in Dayton, Ohio” → “WATCH: Trump Tells Ohio Crowd, “We’re Going to Win Big and We’re Going to Shove it Up Their Ass” While Pointing at the Fake News”
  • The Hill (2 wordings): “Trump backs data centers in Ohio amid tight Senate race” → “Trump to campaign with Husted in Ohio”
  • Yahoo News (2 wordings): “Trump, campaigning in Ohio, says the midterms will bring a ‘big surprise’” → “Trump takes extraordinary steps to target midterms, alarming critics”
Every outlet's first headline (25), left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

Fox News20 min
MSNOW8 min
CNN6 min
  • MONSTER MIDTERMS MASH. TRUMP BARNSTORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY FOR REPUBLICANS Fox News, 5 min
  • DEMOCRAT SHERROD BROWN LOOKS TO WIN BACK OHIO MSNOW, 3 min
  • TRUMP UNLEASHED. 47 MILES UP GOP BASE WITH MULTI-STATE MIDTERMS BLITZ Fox News, 2 min
  • DODGES ON TRUMP MEETING WITH CONVICTED ELECTION DENIER MSNOW, 2 min
  • REPUBLICANS SEEK TO SHORE UP SUPPORT FOR IOWA SENATE NOMINEE CNN, 2 min
  • RACE FOR CONTROL OF THE SENATE Fox News, 2 min
  • TRUMP & VANCE HIT THE TRAIL TO RALLY SUPPORT IN GOP STRONGHOLDS CNN, 2 min
  • FOX POLL: CRUCIAL MI SENATE RACE TIGHT 29 DAYS OUT Fox News, 2 min

📻 On the radio

  • ABC News Update, Oct 5, 5:32 PM ET: story 2 of 3
  • NPR News Now, Oct 5, 10:10 AM ET: the lead
  • ABC News Update, Oct 4, 6:05 PM ET: story 3 of 9
  • ABC News Update, Oct 4, 2:32 PM ET: the lead

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧶 Retold online

  • Trump's appearance in Ohio highlights the GOP's unpopularity due to voter dissatisfaction with his performance. Oct 5: told by 7 people
    🧩 The buck stops here

On Folklore: the latest in full, with their motifs and who is telling them.

🎙️ The same shape, told by voters

What voters in The Focus Group's episodes told that's filed under the same motifs, in our words (not theirs), often from months before.

🗣️ names in it: Donald Trump Jon Husted Sherrod Brown Ohio AP News

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🧵 Trump Ohio campaign rally

  1. Trump and Gruden attend Ohio rally supporting GOP Senate candidate (this story)

    Oct 4, 1 PM ET

  2. Jon Gruden attends Ohio rally for GOP candidate

    Oct 4, 11 PM ET