← the whole motif index

🧩 BND index · M577

Proportional response

People argue over whether a retaliation is proportionate to the harm that provoked it.

βš–οΈ ValuesπŸ—‚οΈ Crime and punishment

⚠️ A story people tell, not a claim that it's true.

A motif is the shape of a story as its tellers tell it, named the way a folklorist names a tale type, so the same story told about other people, by the other side or in another year lands in the same place. Some of the claims below are true, many are false. Arguing against a story is often a story of its own, its answer (Voter fraud is answered by Voter suppression, Lawfare by No one is above the law), and we file it there; where no answer has a motif yet, the arguments against a story sit with its tellings.

πŸ—£οΈ In so many words

the words that carry it

πŸ’¬ the tellers' own words: β€œHamas has committed terrorism but nothing on the scale of Israel.” β€œI said Israel was murdering children and bombing schools. Hamas wasn’t doing that.”

🧢 Its claims

what people have said in this shape, summed up in our words: their claims, not ours, and not checked unless a fact-checker is named; newest first in each; a claim's dots are the shows it came up on, in their lean's color (point at them for their names)

Retold online 1

claims many people posted in their own words

  • 2026-10-07 β€œArguments over whether Israel's conduct in Gaza is worse than Hamas's, and whether it amounts to genocide.” β€” told by people online

M577 Β· first seen 2026-10-07 Β· last 2026-10-17 Β· what this is Β· how the index works