← the whole motif index

🧩 BND index · M1010

Right to exist

Whether a state has a right to exist is argued as a principle: no state has one, every people deserves one, or this one has forfeited it.

πŸ—£οΈ ArgumentsπŸ—‚οΈ War motifs

⚠️ A story people tell, not a claim that it's true.

A motif is the shape of a story as its tellers tell it, named the way a folklorist names a tale type, so the same story told about other people, by the other side or in another year lands in the same place. Some of the claims below are true, many are false. Arguing against a story is often a story of its own, its answer (Voter fraud is answered by Voter suppression, Lawfare by No one is above the law), and we file it there; where no answer has a motif yet, the arguments against a story sit with its tellings.

πŸͺœ Its family

what it rests on, what rests on it, and the motifs that answer it

πŸ”— goes with: 🧩 Self-determination

πŸŽ™οΈ Who it came up with

the shows we follow where its claims came up (1 left-leaning, 0 center, 1 right-leaning so far), colored by the show's lean; the bar is how many of its claims each one heard

  1. 🫏 Pod Save America 1 claim
  2. πŸ”€ The Jimmy Dore Show (podcast) 1 claim
  3. 🐘 The Mark Levin Show 1 claim

"Came up on" means one of its claims was heard on the show: told, reported or argued against. We don't yet mark which. Show leans are our own grouping of the shows we transcribe.

πŸ“° In the news

the stories its claims were told about, the most told first (matched by our tools, so a link can be wrong)

πŸ—£οΈ In so many words

the words that carry it

πŸ’¬ the tellers' own words: β€œDoes Palestine have the right to exist? Yes. Does Israel have the right to exist? Yes, if there is a shared understanding” β€œIsrael does not have a right to exist.” β€œIsrael, and every other state in existence have no right to exist.” β€œNo jurisdiction grants any state, including Israel, the right to exist.” β€œNo state has a right to exist. There is no law that says they do.” β€œStates have powers, people have rights.”

🧢 Its claims

what people have said in this shape, summed up in our words: their claims, not ours, and not checked unless a fact-checker is named; newest first in each; a claim's dots are the shows it came up on, in their lean's color (point at them for their names)

Told on the left 0

claims heard on left-leaning shows, and no right-leaning one

No claim heard only on the left so far.

Told on the right 0

claims heard on right-leaning shows, and no left-leaning one

No claim heard only on the right so far.

Told on both sides 1

claims heard on left- and right-leaning shows alike

  • 2026-11-15 β€œPalestinian people have a right to human rights, safety, and self-determination.” β€” said on 3 shows

Retold online 2

claims many people posted in their own words

  • 2026-10-18 β€œNo state, Israel included, has a right to exist: people have rights, states only have powers, and no law grants states that right.” β€” told by people online
  • 2026-10-18 β€œIsrael does not have a right to exist.” β€” told by people online

M1010 Β· first seen 2026-10-18 Β· last 2026-10-30 Β· what this is Β· how the index works