← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #468

DOJ sues California over suspected noncitizen voters

Oct 14, 11 AM ET to Oct 19, 8 AM ET · 2 outlets not rated for lean

📰 read it at: HuffPostRaw StoryThe GuardianThe New RepublicABC NewsAPAxiosCBS NewsCNBCLos Angeles TimesMediaiteNew York TimesPBS NewsHourThe IndependentYahoo NewsBloombergNewsweekReutersScripps NewsStraight Arrow NewsThe HillWSJJust the NewsThe Epoch TimesThe Washington TimesWashington ExaminerBreitbartFox NewsIJRNew York PostNewsmaxOANPJ MediaRed StateThe BlazeThe Daily CallerThe Daily SignalThe Daily WireThe Gateway PunditThe Post MillennialTalking Points MemoThe Washington Sun

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 14, 1 AM ETfirst on front pages: HuffPost and Reuters
  2. Oct 14, 1 AM ETthe news that day, HuffPost:“DOJ Issues Ultimatum To California: Review List Of Alleged Noncitizen Voters Or Else!”
  3. Oct 14, 1 PM ETfirst on the radio: ABC News Update
  4. Oct 14, 5 PM ETfirst on TV: CNN
  5. Oct 15, 4 PM ETthe news that day, New York Times:“Trump Administration Sues California Over Voter Rolls”
  6. Oct 16, 3 PM ETpeak: on 35 front pages at once
  7. Oct 16, 11 PM ETthe news that day, Washington Examiner:“Trump vows jail time for California officials counting ballots from noncitizens”
  8. Oct 17, 7 AM ETthe news that day, Red State:“Lock Them Up: Trump Promises Prison Time for CA Officials Pushing Noncitizen Votes”

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

📡 Wire copy

2 outlets ran the AP, Reuters headline nearly word for word

HuffPost, Yahoo News

💬 Quoted

  1. “go to jail”1
  2. “Non-Citizens”1
  3. “Likely Noncitizens”2
  4. “They Will All Go to Jail For a Long Period of Time!!!”3
  5. “Jail”4
  6. “likely noncitizens”4
  7. “state-facilitated voter fraud,”1
  8. “TIME IS UP FOR CALIFORNIA!”1

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

🗣️ Only one side says

  • 🫏 left
  • threatens california
  • trump administration threatens
  • 🐘 right
  • jail time

phrases three or more outlets on one side used and none on the other

📌 Linked by aggregators

3 Real Clear Politics · Google News · Political Wire

aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)

✏️ 25 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • ABC News (2 wordings): “DOJ sues California over alleged non-citizens on voter rolls” → “Trump administration threatens to prosecute local California election workers”
  • Axios (2 wordings): “DOJ gives California 48 hours to check voters or face lawsuit” → “Trump sues California to prevent counting 20,000 voters' ballots”
  • Breitbart (3 wordings): “DOJ Forcing California to Review List with Possible Noncitizens on Voter Rolls” → “Trump Warns California Election Officials of Jail Time if They Let Noncitizens Vote”
  • CBS News (3 wordings): “DOJ tells California to review whether noncitizens got mail ballots” → “Justice Dept. sues California, claims noncitizens were sent ballots”
  • HuffPost (3 wordings): “DOJ Issues Ultimatum To California: Review List Of Alleged Noncitizen Voters Or Else!” → “Trump Threatens California Officials With Imprisonment Over Stance On Mail Ballots”
  • Just the News (3 wordings): “Justice Department demands California review list of suspected noncitizens who are on voter rolls” → “DOJ sues California for 'state-facilitated voter fraud,' citing 20,000 suspected foreign voters”
  • Los Angeles Times (3 wordings): “Justice Dept. demands California prove citizenship for lists of voters or withhold ballots” → “Justice Dept. sues California, seeks to stop state from counting 20,000 ballots”
  • New York Post (4 wordings): “California given master list of alleged non-American voters in state, given 48-hour ultimatum: feds” → “Trump admin issues stark warning to California ballot counters after suing state over 20K suspected noncitizen voters”
  • New York Times (2 wordings): “Trump Administration Sues California Over Voter Rolls” → “Justice Department Sues California Over Voter Rolls”
  • Newsmax (5 wordings): “With Calif. Ultimatum, DOJ Ratchets Up Nationwide Voting Fight” → “DOJ Seeks to Block 20K Calif. Ballots Over Citizenship”
  • Newsweek (2 wordings): “How Trump DOJ Flagged 20K California Voters Feds Suspect Are Noncitizens” → “Trump Threatens ‘Jail’ In California Midterm Election Fight”
  • Raw Story (2 wordings): “DOJ threatens California with 48-hour demand in 'unprecedented' midterm move: Reuters” → “Alarms blare over Trump DOJ's new demand for California elections: 'Real escalation'”
  • Red State (4 wordings): “DOJ Warns CA Against Counting Suspected Noncitizen Ballots, Sets 48-Hour Compliance Deadline” → “Lock Them Up: Trump Promises Prison Time for CA Officials Pushing Noncitizen Votes”
  • Reuters (6 wordings): “EXCLUSIVE: US Justice Department threatens California over alleged noncitizen voters, letter shows” → “Trump threatens California officials with imprisonment over stance on mail ballots - Reuters”
  • Straight Arrow News (2 wordings): “Trump DOJ wants California to block ballots. The state disputes its evidence” → “Trump administration takes another swing at California over voter fraud claims”
  • The Daily Caller (2 wordings): “DOJ Sues California, Alleging 20K Noncitizens Are Registered On State Voter RollDOJ Sues California, Alleging 20K Noncitizens Are Registered On State Voter Roll” → “DOJ Sues California, Alleging 20K Noncitizens Are Registered On State Voter Roll”
  • The Daily Signal (2 wordings): “Justice Department Sues California Over ‘Likely’ Noncitizens on Voter Lists” → “DOJ Sues California After State Refuses to Act on Suspected Noncitizen Voters”
  • The Epoch Times (2 wordings): “DOJ Gives California 48 Hours to Review Suspected Noncitizen Voters” → “DOJ Sues California After Flagging 20,000 ‘Likely Noncitizens’ Registered to Vote”
  • The Gateway Pundit (4 wordings): “DOJ Gives California 48 Hours to Check Noncitizen Names on Voter Rolls or Face Emergency Action Before Midterms” → ““They Will All Go to Jail For a Long Period of Time!!!” – Trump and DOJ Vow to Jail Los Angeles County Election Officials Who Tabulate Ballots of Non-Citizens”
  • The Guardian (3 wordings): “DoJ threatens California over alleged noncitizen voting as Trump tries to rally support for Republicans” → “Trump administration threatens California officials if noncitizens vote in midterms”
  • The Hill (5 wordings): “DOJ faces legal threats after pushing California to match voter list with USB drive” → “Trump: California officials will ‘go to jail’ if state ignores DOJ voter ...”
  • The Wall Street Journal (2 wordings): “DOJ Sues California to Block Ballots from 20,000 Voters” → “DOJ Sues California to Block Ballots From 20,000 Voters”
  • The Washington Sun (2 wordings): “DOJ Gives California Election Officials a Thumb Drive and an Ultimatum” → “DOJ Hits California With New Lawsuit Following Voter List Ultimatum”
  • Washington Examiner (4 wordings): “DOJ demands California review list of ‘likely noncitizens’ who received mail-in ballots” → “Trump vows jail time for California officials counting ballots from noncitizens”
  • Yahoo News (3 wordings): “Exclusive-US Justice Department threatens California over alleged noncitizen voters, letter shows” → “Trump administration sues California to block state from counting alleged noncitizen mail-in ballots”
📰 Every outlet's headline 42left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. 🫏 MSNOW 11 min
  2. 🫏 CNN 9 min
  3. 🐘 Fox News 8 min

📻 On the radio

hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order

  1. 🫏 NPR News Now 10× · 🥇 led 1
  2. 🫏 ABC News Update 6× · 🥇 led 3

🎙️ On the shows

podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation

  1. ⚖️ Bloomberg News Now 5
  2. ⚖️ Up First (NPR) 1

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces

🕵️🤷 No investigator or satirist matched to it yet.

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

  • 🧩 Voter suppression 🫏 1 left show ⚖️ 1 center show 🐘 3 right shows 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Voter fraud
    as told: “The DOJ gave California election officials a list of suspected noncitizen voters and an ultimatum to segregate their ballots or face legal action.” and 2 more
  • 🧩 Seize the ballots 🫏 1 left show ⚖️ 1 center show 🐘 3 right shows
    as told: “The Trump DOJ is suing California over allegedly ineligible voters to seize ballots.”
  • 🧩 They're going to steal it 🫏 1 left show ⚖️ 1 center show 🐘 3 right shows
    as told: “The Trump DOJ is suing California over allegedly ineligible voters to seize ballots.”
  • 🧩 Too stupid to understand 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: They think you're stupid
    as told: “A large segment of the American electorate is incredibly stupid.”
  • 🧩 Voter fraud 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Voter suppression
    as told: “The DOJ gave California election officials a list of suspected noncitizen voters and an ultimatum to segregate their ballots or face legal action.” and 3 more

🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🗣️ Names in it

Justice DepartmentCalifornia

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🧵 DOJ California voter fraud case

  1. DOJ warns California election officials of legal risks for counting suspected noncitizen ballots

    Oct 17, 9 PM ET

  2. DOJ sues California over suspected noncitizen voters (this story)

    Oct 14, 11 AM ET

  3. DOJ charges 28 noncitizens in California voter fraud case

    Oct 19, 2 PM ET

  4. Justice Department seeks court order over alleged noncitizen voters in California

    Oct 21, 12 PM ET

  5. DOJ charges 48 noncitizens with election crimes

    Oct 26, 6 PM ET

  6. Judge questions doj's claims of noncitizens on California voter rolls

    Oct 23, 9 PM ET

  7. Justice Department subpoenas California election officials in voter rolls investigation

    Oct 29, 7 PM ET

  8. Appeals court rejects DOJ request to set aside California ballots

    Oct 25, 10 PM ET

  9. Analysis finds over 40% of names on DOJ list not on California voter rolls

    Nov 1, 1 PM ET

  10. Ninth Circuit allows Trump administration to request noncitizen ballot separation

    Nov 3, 8 PM ET

  11. Supreme court rejects Trump administration bid to set aside California ballots

    Nov 2, 1 PM ET

  12. Justice Department drops lawsuit against California over disputed ballots

    Nov 6, 11 PM ET