← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #357

Russia and Ukraine continue energy strikes despite Trump's ceasefire claims

Oct 12, 9 AM ET to Oct 15, 9 AM ET · 3 outlets not rated for lean

📰 read it at: HuffPostThe BulwarkThe GuardianABC NewsAPAxiosCBS NewsCNBCCNNMediaiteMilitary.comNBC NewsNPRNew York TimesPBS NewsHourSemaforThe IndependentTimeUSA TodayYahoo NewsBBCBloombergChicago TribuneFinancial TimesFortuneMarketWatchNews NationNewsweekReutersScripps NewsStraight Arrow NewsThe HillFox BusinessJust the NewsThe Epoch TimesThe SunThe Washington TimesWashington ExaminerBreitbartFox NewsIJRNew York PostNewsmaxOANRed StateThe Daily CallerThe Gateway PunditThe Western JournalTownhallCrooks and LiarsRFE/RLThe Washington Sun

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 10, 2 PM ETfirst on a front page: AP
  2. Oct 10, 6 PM ETthe news that day, The Bulwark:“Zelensky Defies Trump, Strikes Putin Where It Hurts Most”
  3. Oct 11, 11 AM ETthe news that day, Just the News:“Trump announces ‘energy ceasefire’ in Ukraine war”
  4. Oct 12, 9 AM ETfirst on TV: BBC News
  5. Oct 12, 12 PM ETfirst on the radio: NPR News Now
  6. Oct 12, 3 PM ETpeak: on 52 front pages at once
  7. Oct 12, 3 PM ETthe news that day, NPR:“Russia hits Ukraine gas facilities after Trump claims 'energy ceasefire'”
  8. Oct 13, 2 PM ETthe news that day, Just the News:“Trump says Ukraine, Russia 'a little off' as energy strikes continue”
  9. Oct 14, 6 AM ETthe news that day, Bloomberg:“Russia Hits Ukraine Energy Plants in a Blow to Trump”

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

📡 Wire copy

1 outlet ran the AP, Reuters headline nearly word for word

Military.com

💬 Quoted

  1. “energy ceasefire”1
  2. “Energy Ceasefire”3
  3. “because I said they agree”1
  4. “Break”1
  5. “We will stop”1
  6. “truce”1
  7. “They're both a little off”2
  8. “Agreed”1

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

🗣️ Only one side says

  • 🫏 left
  • energy sites despite trump
  • russia keeps striking ukraine's
  • 🐘 right
  • nothing of its own

phrases three or more outlets on one side used and none on the other

📌 Linked by aggregators

2 Political Wire · Google News

aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)

✏️ 31 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • ABC News (2 wordings): “Zelenskyy: 'We will stop' strikes on Russian diesel if Russia pauses attacks” → “Russia strikes power plant in Eastern Ukraine”
  • AP (2 wordings): “Trump says Ukraine should get a new president as he blames Zelenskyy for US diesel prices” → “Zelenskyy says Russia keeps striking Ukraine’s energy sites despite Trump ceasefire push”
  • Axios (2 wordings): “Trump claims Russia and Ukraine agree to energy ceasefire” → “Trump bears down on Zelensky as Russia keeps up attacks on Ukraine”
  • BBC (4 wordings): “Watch: What's behind Trump's energy ceasefire claim?” → “Why Moscow is staying tight-lipped on Trump's energy ceasefire”
  • Bloomberg (6 wordings): “Trump Says Russia and Ukraine Agreed to ‘Energy Ceasefire’ The day before, Trump had again demanded that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy halt attacks on Russian oil refineries.” → “Zelenskyy Defies Trump and Orders New Russian Refinery Attacks”
  • Breitbart (5 wordings): “Trump Announces Ukraine-Russia Ceasefire on Energy Infrastructure” → “Zelensky: Russia Attacked Ukrainian Facilities Despite Trump’s Ceasefire”
  • CBS News (2 wordings): “Trump announces Russia-Ukraine "energy ceasefire" after criticizing Zelenskyy” → “Zelenskyy says Russia isn't honoring Trump's energy ceasefire”
  • CNBC (2 wordings): “Brent tops $106 after deadly Saudi airport attack, Ukraine says Russia violated energy ceasefire” → “Zelenskyy accuses Russia of violating Trump’s energy ceasefire”
  • CNN (2 wordings): “Zelensky says Russia has already violated Trump’s surprise energy ceasefire” → “Trump suggests Russia and Ukraine did not agree to his ‘energy ceasefire’ before he announced it”
  • Financial Times (3 wordings): “Putin is breaching Trump’s ‘energy ceasefire’, Zelenskyy says” → “Why Trump is going for Zelenskyy’s jugular”
  • Fox News (5 wordings): “Trump announces partial Russia-Ukraine ceasefire after explosive clash with Zelenskyy” → “Zelenskyy sends clear message to Trump after accusing Putin of defying partial ceasefire”
  • Just the News (3 wordings): “Trump announces ‘energy ceasefire’ in Ukraine war” → “Trump says Ukraine, Russia 'a little off' as energy strikes continue”
  • Mediaite (2 wordings): “Zelensky Jabs Trump’s Truth Social ‘ENERGY CEASEFIRE’ Pronouncement After Putin Attack” → “Critics Eviscerate Trump’s Bizarre Claim Russia and Ukraine ‘Agreed’ to His Ceasefire: ‘That’s Not How This Works’”
  • Military.com (2 wordings): “Trump Says Russia and Ukraine Reach ‘Energy Ceasefire’ But Gives No Details” → “Zelenskyy Says Russia Keeps Striking Ukraine’s Energy Sites Despite Trump Ceasefire Push”
  • NBC News (2 wordings): “Trump claims Russia and Ukraine agree to energy ceasefire, but Kyiv says strikes continue” → “Energy prices rise after Trump’s ‘energy ceasefire’ fails to move Russia or Ukraine”
  • NPR (3 wordings): “Trump says Russia and Ukraine agree to an 'energy ceasefire'” → “Zelenskyy tells NPR Ukraine wants peace but will hit Russia until it follows ceasefire”
  • New York Post (3 wordings): “Ukrainian President Zelensky said that Russia has continued to strike Ukraine’s energy facilities even after President Trump said that the warring countries had agreed on an energy ceasefire.” → “Ukraine got no warning about latest Russian strikes on Kyiv, Zelensky says after latest Trump critique”
  • New York Times (2 wordings): “Ukraine shrugs off Trump call to ditch Zelensky for energy strikes” → “Ukraine Shrugs Off Trump Call to Ditch Zelensky for Energy Strikes”
  • News Nation (2 wordings): “Trump claims energy ceasefire reached between Russia and Ukraine” → “Backlash over Russia diesel deal as Trump claims Ukraine energy ceasefire”
  • Newsmax (4 wordings): “Kyiv Says Russian Strikes on Energy Facilities Continue Despite Trump's 'energy Ceasefire'” → “Zelenskyy: Russia Defies Trump's Energy Ceasefire Push”
  • Newsweek (2 wordings): “Trump Announces ‘Energy Ceasefire’ Between Russia and Ukraine” → “Who Could Replace Zelensky: 4 Contenders as Trump Calls for Change”
  • PBS NewsHour (2 wordings): “Trump claims Russia and Ukraine agree to 'energy ceasefire' despite continued attacks” → “Ukraine disputes Trump's claim of energy ceasefire as Russian diesel deal draws fire”
  • Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty (4 wordings): “Trump Announces Energy Cease-Fire Between Ukraine, Russia As Countries Trade Strikes” → “Zelenskyy Accuses Russia Of Breaking Trump's Cease-Fire On Energy Strikes”
  • Reuters (7 wordings): “Kyiv says Russia hits energy targets despite Trump ceasefire” → “Allies failed to warn Ukraine of impending missile attack, Zelenskiy says”
  • The Daily Caller (2 wordings): “Trump Announces ‘Energy Ceasefire’ Between Russia, Ukraine” → “Trump’s ‘Energy Ceasefire’ In Ukraine Was Fake News, Officials Say”
  • The Epoch Times (3 wordings): “Trump: Russia and Ukraine Agree to ‘Energy Ceasefire’” → “Zelenskyy Says Strikes on Russian Refineries Will Continue If Putin Rejects Energy Ceasefire”
  • The Gateway Pundit (2 wordings): “JUST IN: Russia Strikes Ukrainian Power Plant After Trump Announces Energy Ceasefire, Zelensky Says (VIDEO)” → “Trump Says He’s “Not Sure” Russian Strikes on Ukrainian Power Plant Violated Ceasefire – “There’s Been Violations on Both Sides” (VIDEO)”
  • The Guardian (4 wordings): “Russia hit Ukraine power plant ‘immediately after’ Trump declared energy ceasefire, says Zelenskyy” → “Russia and Ukraine resume energy strikes despite Trump warnings”
  • The Hill (5 wordings): “Backlash grows against Russia diesel deal as Trump claims Ukraine energy ceasefire” → “Trump on Russia, Ukraine attacks: ‘They’re both a little off’”
  • The Washington Times (2 wordings): “Trump says Kyiv, Moscow agree to stop attacking each other's energy facilities” → “Zelenskyy tells Warsaw forum Russian drones defied Trump’s truce: ‘Putin does not read Truth Social’”
  • Washington Examiner (5 wordings): “Trump announces immediate ‘energy ceasefire’ between Russia and Ukraine” → “Trump insists Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire is real”
📰 Every outlet's headline 52left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. ⚖️ BBC News 259 min
  2. 🫏 CNN 47 min
  3. 🐘 Fox News 12 min
  4. 🫏 MSNOW 7 min

📻 On the radio

hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order

  1. 🫏 NPR News Now 16× · 🥇 led 8
  2. 🫏 ABC News Update 2× · best #2

🎙️ On the shows

podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation

  1. ⚖️ Bloomberg News Now 4
  2. ⚖️ Up First (NPR) 2
  3. 🐘 Benny Johnson 2
  4. 🫏 MeidasTouch 1
  5. ⚖️ BBC Global News Podcast 1
  6. ⚖️ The Intelligence (Economist) 1
  7. 🫏 Adam Mockler 1
  8. 🫏 Hasan Piker 1
  9. 🐘 Ben Shapiro 1
  10. 🐘 Morning Wire 1
  11. ➕ 5 more shows 5

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces

  1. 🕵️ Just Security 1
  2. 🃏 The Hard Times 1

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

  • 🧩 Peace in our time 🫏 6 left shows ⚖️ 5 center shows 🐘 1 right show 🧶 online
    as told: “Donald Trump falsely claims that Russia and Ukraine have agreed to a ceasefire.” and 1 more

🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🗣️ Names in it

RussiaUkraineDonald TrumpVolodymyr Zelenskyy

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🧵 Trump-Russia diesel deal

  1. U.s.-russia talks include oil deal linked to trump allies

    Oct 3, 5 PM ET

  2. Trump criticizes Ukraine after attack on Russian diesel hub

    Oct 10, 2 PM ET

  3. Trump claims Ukraine and Russia agreed to energy ceasefire

    Oct 11, 11 AM ET

  4. Russian attacks kill 15 in Ukraine after diesel deal with Trump

    Oct 10, 9 AM ET

  5. Senators urge Trump to reverse Russian diesel plan

    Oct 12, 12 PM ET

  6. US threatens to suspend arms shipments to Ukraine over refinery attacks

    Oct 12, 3 PM ET

  7. Senator Tillis says trump's Russian diesel deal may be illegal

    Oct 12, 7 PM ET

  8. Russia and Ukraine continue energy strikes despite Trump's ceasefire claims (this story)

    Oct 12, 9 AM ET

  9. Uk prime minister Burnham pledges support to Zelenskyy

    Oct 14, 4 PM ET

  10. Zelenskyy says he feels betrayed after Trump’s diesel deal with Russia

    Oct 14, 6 PM ET

  11. Zelenskyy meets EU leaders as rift with Trump deepens

    Oct 16, 1 PM ET

  12. Trump announces diesel fuel deal with Russia to address elevated prices

    Oct 9, 4 PM ET

  13. Russian diesel tanker heads to U.S. under Trump-Putin deal

    Oct 23, 10 AM ET

  14. Melania Trump brokers localized ceasefire in occupied Ukrainian city

    Oct 23, 11 AM ET

  15. Melania Trump-brokered ceasefire begins in Russian-occupied Ukrainian city

    Oct 27, 1 AM ET

  16. Evacuees from Russian-occupied Oleshky arrive in Ukraine amid ceasefire

    Oct 30, 8 AM ET

  17. Melania trump-brokered ceasefire ends as Russian strikes resume

    Nov 2, 12 PM ET

  18. Melania Trump hosts Russia and Ukraine officials at White House

    Nov 3, 12 PM ET