🗞️ Story file #1689
Trump proposes amnesty deal with Democrats Nov 9, 2 PM ET to Nov 11, 6 AM ET
🗣️ in it: Donald Trump MAGA White House Democratic Party Illegal aliens
🔔 Notify me
👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through
TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is
part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say
how each is made.
📰 9 front pages over its life ⚖️ 🫏2 · 1 · 6🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 16 hours on the front pages 📈 8 front pages at once, at its peak 📺 5 min of TV captions 🧵 3 stories in its saga 🕰️ Crossed the aisle in 5 hours: first on the right (The Daily Signal, 2:03 PM), on the left by 7:02 PM (Vox).
📰 read it at:
Vox CNN WSJ The Washington Times Fox News Newsmax The Daily Caller The Daily Signal The National Desk
📰 Spread the front pages that ran it, hour by hour
📊 by lean
🛤️ who had it
4 8 Mon Tue Wed peak: 8 front pages, Tue 6 AM Mon Nov 9, 2 PM ET: on 1 front pages (1 right)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 3 PM ET: on 4 front pages (4 right)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 4 PM ET: on 5 front pages (4 right, 1 leans right)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 5 PM ET: on 5 front pages (4 right, 1 leans right)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 6 PM ET: on 5 front pages (4 right, 1 leans right)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 7 PM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 8 PM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 9 PM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 10 PM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Mon Nov 9, 11 PM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 12 AM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 1 AM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 2 AM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 3 AM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 4 AM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 5 AM ET: on 7 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants” (The Daily Signal) Tue Nov 10, 6 AM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 7 AM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 8 AM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 9 AM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 10 AM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 11 AM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 12 PM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 1 PM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 2 PM ET: on 8 front pages (5 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy” (The National Desk) Tue Nov 10, 3 PM ET: on 3 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 4 PM ET: on 3 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 5 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 6 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 7 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 8 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 9 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 10 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Tue Nov 10, 11 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 12 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 1 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 2 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 3 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 4 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 5 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Wed Nov 11, 6 AM ET: on 4 front pages (1 right, 1 left, 1 leans left, 1 center)
“Trump’s mixed messages on immigration” (Vox) Front pages carrying it each hour, by the outlets' lean, the side that had it first at the bottom: left leans left center leans right right.
First: The Daily Signal, Mon 2:03 PM ET. Nov 9, 6 PM Nov 10 6 AM 12 PM 6 PM Nov 11 6 AM The Daily SignalThe Daily Signal The Daily Signal, Nov 9, 2:03 PM ET: Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants The Daily CallerThe Daily Caller The Daily Caller, Nov 9, 3:03 PM ET: EXCLUSIVE: White House Scrambles After Trump Again Floats Amnesty Deal With Democrats NewsmaxNewsmax Newsmax, Nov 9, 3:03 PM ET: Deportations to Continue Despite Midterm Losses Fox NewsFox News Fox News, Nov 9, 3:03 PM ET: White House doubles down after Trump angers base by floating illegal alien deal with Dems The Washington TimesThe Washington Times The Washington Times, Nov 9, 4:02 PM ET: Trump's second-guessing mass deportations seen as opening for Democrats, while conservatives seethe The National DeskThe National Desk The National Desk, Nov 9, 7:02 PM ET: Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy VoxVox Vox, Nov 9, 7:02 PM ET: Trump’s mixed messages on immigration CNNCNN CNN, Nov 10, 6:02 AM ET: Analysis Trump ticks off MAGA with bizarre immigration comments WSJThe Wall Street Journal The Wall Street Journal, Nov 10, 5:02 PM ET: Opinion | Is Trump Getting the Voters’ Message on Immigration? 📺 TV CNN, 12:40 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, 12:40 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, 12:41 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, 12:41 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, 12:42 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, 12:42 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, 12:43 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline
from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not
rated); a dot marks a new headline, and a headline swapped for a new one between our hourly looks runs on to
it. A gap means a look found the story gone from that front page. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it
(bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details. 💬 Quoted
“Too Tough” 2 “Pretty Far Right” 1 “Work a Deal” 1 “Too Tough,” 1 phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did
📌 Linked by aggregators
1 Real Clear Politics
aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)
📰 Every outlet's headline 9 left to right by AllSides rating Vox🕒 Nov 9, 7 PM ET
Trump’s mixed messages on immigration ↗ CNN🕒 Nov 10, 6 AM ET
Analysis Trump ticks off MAGA with bizarre immigration comments ↗ WSJ🕒 Nov 10, 5 PM ET
Opinion | Is Trump Getting the Voters’ Message on Immigration? ↗ The Washington Times🕒 Nov 9, 4 PM ET
Trump's second-guessing mass deportations seen as opening for Democrats, while conservatives seethe ↗ Fox News🕒 Nov 9, 3 PM ET
White House doubles down after Trump angers base by floating illegal alien deal with Dems ↗ Newsmax🕒 Nov 9, 3 PM ET
Deportations to Continue Despite Midterm Losses ↗ The Daily Caller🕒 Nov 9, 3 PM ET
EXCLUSIVE: White House Scrambles After Trump Again Floats Amnesty Deal With Democrats ↗ The Daily Signal🕒 Nov 9, 2 PM ET
Trump Teases Controversial Deal With Democrats on Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants ↗ The National Desk🕒 Nov 9, 7 PM ET
Trump gives mixed messages on immigration strategy ↗ 📡 Broadcast TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it
📺 On TV minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean
🫏
CNN
5 min 📻 On the radio hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order
No radio newscast matched to it.
🎙️ On the shows podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation
🐘
Erick Erickson
1 🕵️ Investigated, joked about 🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces
🃏
NewsThump
1 🧶 Retelling what people online made of it
The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.
🧩 Amnesty is a magnet
🐘 5 right shows as told: “Donald Trump's suggestion of a deal for certain illegal immigrants constitutes amnesty.” 🧩 They betrayed us
🐘 5 right shows ↔️ its answer: Promises made, promises kept as told: “Donald Trump's suggestion of a deal for certain illegal immigrants constitutes amnesty.” Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.
🔎 Checking what the fact-checkers looked into
No fact-checker has taken it on yet.
🧵 Persistence the running story it belongs to
🧵 Trump immigration deal talks →
1 2 Nov 10, 2 PM ET · 📍 this story
Trump proposes amnesty deal with Democrats
3