๐๏ธ Story file #1539
Trump names Stephen Miller as new White House chief of staff
Nov 6, 2 PM ET to Nov 10, 4 PM ET ยท 2 outlets not rated for lean
๐ฃ How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.
- 70front pages over its life
- ๐ซ32 ยท 12 ยท 24๐left ยท center ยท right
- 4.1 dayson the front pages
- 66front pages at once, at its peak
- 303 minof TV captions
- 73radio newscasts
- 3stories in its saga
๐ฐ read it at:
Alternet
HuffPost
Mother Jones
New York Magazine
Raw Story
Rolling Stone
The Atlantic
The Bulwark
The Daily Beast
The Daily Kos
The Guardian
The New Republic
Vox
ABC News
Axios
CBS News
CNN
Los Angeles Times
Mediaite
NBC News
NPR
New York Times
PBS NewsHour
Politico
SemaforStar Tribune
The Independent
The Washington PostThe Week
Time
USA Today
Yahoo News
BBC
Bloomberg
Chicago TribuneFinancial Times
Forbes
News Nation
Newsweek
Reason
Reuters
Scripps News
Tampa Bay Times
The Hill
Just the News
The American Conservative
The Epoch Times
The Free Press
The Sun
The Washington Times
Washington Examiner
Breitbart
Fox News
New York Post
Newsmax
OAN
PJ Media
Red State
The Blaze
The Daily Caller
The Daily Signal
The Daily Wire
The Federalist
The Gateway Pundit
The National Pulse
The Post Millennial
The Western Journal
TownhallWashington Reporter
Zeteo
Nov 6, 2 PM ET
first on TV: MSNOW
Nov 6, 2 PM ET
first on front pages: 7 front pages at once
Nov 6, 3 PM ET
the news that day, BBC:
โTrump names Stephen Miller as new chief of staffโ
Nov 6, 3 PM ET
first on the radio: NPR News Now
Nov 6, 7 PM ET
peak: on 66 front pages at once
Nov 7, 2 PM ET
the news that day, Newsmax:
โStephen Miller Pledges 'Absolute Loyalty' to Trumpโ
Nov 8, 7 PM ET
the news that day, Newsmax:
โWhite House Deputy Chief of Staff to Exitโ
Nov 9, 11 AM ET
the news that day, Axios:
โTop White House Official Flees After Miller Takeover...โ
๐ฐ Spread
the front pages that ran it, hour by hour
- 1Nov 6โTrump names Stephen Miller as new chief of staffโBBC
- 2Nov 7โStephen Miller Pledges 'Absolute Loyalty' to TrumpโNewsmax
- 3Nov 8โWhite House Deputy Chief of Staff to ExitโNewsmax
- 4Nov 9โTop White House Official Flees After Miller Takeover...โAxios
๐ก Wire copy
2 outlets ran the Reuters headline nearly word for word
One America News Network, Scripps News
๐ฌ Quoted
- โmistakeโ1
- โNot Worriedโ2
- โdouble down on Trumpismโ1
- โa bad mistakeโ2
- โFear and vitriolโ1
- โColossal Mistakeโ3
- โnot worriedโ2
- โReally oddโ1
phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did
๐ Linked by aggregators
4 Google News ยท Political Wire ยท Real Clear Politics ยท Drudge Report
aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)
โธ โ๏ธ 42 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
- ABC News (3 wordings): โTrump says chief of staff Susie Wiles outโ โ โRelated: Trump says chief of staff Susie Wiles out, Stephen Miller will replace herโ
- Axios (5 wordings): โTrump replaces chief of staff Susie Wiles with Stephen Millerโ โ โTop White House Official Flees After Miller Takeover...โ
- BBC (4 wordings): โTrump names Stephen Miller as new chief of staffโ โ โWith Stephen Miller pick, Trump readies for a battleโ
- Breitbart (7 wordings): โMiller Time: Stephen New Chief of Staff Wiles Out in Post-Election Shake-upโ โ โSanders: 'Not Worriedโ Stephen Miller Becoming White House Chief of Staffโ
- CBS News (3 wordings): โTrump installs Stephen Miller as chief of staff, replacing Susie Wilesโ โ โWhat Stephen Miller has pushed for while in Trump administrationโ
- CNN (5 wordings): โBreaking News Stephen Miller will become White House chief of staff, Trump announces The move comes three days after Republicans suffered catastrophic losses in the midterm electionsโ โ โHow Trumpโs most controversial adviser rose to chief of staff Stephen Miller's elevation sends an unmistakable message: Trump is doubling downโ
- Chicago Tribune (2 wordings): โPresident Donald Trump replaces Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as chief of staff after GOPโs midterm defeatโ โ โWhat Donald Trumpโs new White House chief of staff has said on immigration, childhood vaccines, foreign policyโ
- Financial Times (3 wordings): โTrump to replace Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as chief of staffโ โ โTrump taps immigration hardliner Stephen Miller as chief of staffโ
- Fox News (6 wordings): โTrump taps Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff, replacing Susie Wilesโ โ โDeputy White House Chief of Staff Richard Walters exits job ahead of Stephen Miller takeoverโ
- HuffPost (3 wordings): โStephen Miller Will Replace Susie Wiles As Trump's Chief Of Staffโ โ โReelected GOP Rep: Trump Should Have Fired Stephen Miller, Not Promoted Himโ
- Just the News (3 wordings): โTrump names Stephen Miller as next chief of staff, starting Mondayโ โ โDeputy chief of staff Walters leaves White House ahead of Millerโs arrival as chief of staffโ
- Mediaite (6 wordings): โBREAKING: Trump Reveals Susie Wiles is OUT as WH Chief of Staff โ And Stephen Miller is INโ โ โWhite House Deputy Chief of Staff To Leave After Stephen Millerโs Elevation To Top Postโ
- NBC News (5 wordings): โTrump names Stephen Miller his new chief of staff, replacing Susie Wilesโ โ โMAHA rejoices as Stephen Miller takes over as chief of staffโ
- New York Magazine (6 wordings): โTrump Is Making Stephen Miller His Chief of Staff: Live Updates Here are the latest post-midterms developments.โ โ โTrump Is Going Full Stephen Miller More on the presidentโs big double-down and other midterms aftershocks.โ
- New York Post (10 wordings): โPresident Trump on Friday announced that he was replacing Susie Wiles as his chief of staff with his longtime adviser Stephen Miller following Republicansโ landslide midterm election loss.โ โ โStephen universe New White House chief of staff has message for Trump in first speech since Susie Wiles ousterโ
- New York Times (4 wordings): โWhat to Know About Stephen Miller, Trumpโs New Chief of Staffโ โ โTrump Has Found His New Roy Cohn in Stephen Millerโ
- News Nation (2 wordings): โWho is Stephen Miller, Trump's incoming White House chief of staff?โ โ โTrump promotes Stephen Miller to chief of staff; Wiles leaving adminโ
- Newsmax (6 wordings): โTrump Replaces Wiles With Stephen Miller as Chief of Staffโ โ โWhite House Deputy Chief of Staff to Exitโ
- Newsweek (4 wordings): โStephen Miller Replaces Susie Wiles as White House Chief of Staffโ โ โTrumpโs White House Staffer Shake-Up: Who Could Be Next to Go After Wiles?โ
- One America News Network (2 wordings): โSusie Wiles departs WH Chief of Staff role, calls serving Trump an โHonorโโ โ โTrump: Stephen Miller to become new WH Chief of Staffโ
- PBS NewsHour (3 wordings): โTrump names Stephen Miller his next chief of staff after major Republican midterm lossesโ โ โWhat Trump picking Stephen Miller for chief of staff signals about his agendaโ
- Raw Story (5 wordings): โTrump dumps Susie Wiles and hands the White House to Stephen Miller after midterm routโ โ โEx-Trump insider returns with 'firsthand' Stephen Miller warning: 'Most dangerous'โ
- Red State (4 wordings): โBREAKING Big News: Susie Wiles Out As WH Chief of Staff (Updated)โ โ โClues Emerge on Why Trump Tapped Stephen Miller As New White House Chief of Staffโ
- Reuters (8 wordings): โTrump promotes Stephen Miller to post of chief of staffโ โ โWith Stephen Miller at the helm, Trump charts a course for conflictโ
- Star Tribune (2 wordings): โTrump replaces Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as chief of staff after GOP's midterm defeatโ โ โStephen Miller replaces Susie Wiles as Trump's White House chief of staff after GOP's midterm defeatโ
- Tampa Bay Times (2 wordings): โFlorida veteran politico Susie Wiles exiting Trump White House โข News commentโ โ โFlorida veteran politico Susie Wiles exiting Trump White Houseโ
- The Bulwark (2 wordings): โSam Stein BREAKING: Trump Picks Stephen Miller to Replace Susie Wiles as Chief of Staff A recording from The Bulwarkโs live videoโ โ โBREAKING: Trump Picks Stephen Miller to Replace Susie Wiles as Chief of Staffโ
- The Daily Beast (5 wordings): โTrump Fires Susie Wiles and Promotes Reviled Aide in White House Purgeโ โ โTop White House Official Flees After Stephen Millerโs Takeoverโ
- The Daily Wire (3 wordings): โSusie Wiles Out, Stephen Miller In As White House Chief Of Staffโ โ โStephen Miller Is All In After Promotion To White House Chief Of Staffโ
- The Epoch Times (3 wordings): โTrump Names Stephen Miller to Replace Susie Wiles as Chief of Staffโ โ โStephen Miller Responds to Being Named Chief of Staff as Deputy Steps Downโ
- The Federalist (2 wordings): โStephen Miller To Take Over As White House Chief Of Staffโ โ โBreaking News Alert *** Breaking *** Stephen Miller To Take Over As White House Chief Of Staff Breaking ***โ
- The Gateway Pundit (7 wordings): โBREAKING: Susie Wiles OUT as Trump Chief of Staff โ Stephen Miller to Take on Roleโ โ โDeputy White House Chief of Staff Richard Walters, Longtime Ally of Susie Wiles, Resignsโ
- The Guardian (6 wordings): โDemocrats blast Trumpโs decision to appoint Stephen Miller as chief of staff in wake of Republican midterm routโ โ โHardline Trump aide Stephen Miller takes over as White House chief of staffโ
- The Hill (11 wordings): โFormer Trump staffer calls for Wiles to resign over midterm wipeoutโ โ โWatch live: Trump briefs media as Miller takes over top White House postโ
- The Independent (3 wordings): โTrump axes chief of staff Susie Wiles for Stephen Miller after resounding midterms defeatโ โ โTop White House staffer leaves after Stephen Miller promotedโ
- The National Pulse (2 wordings): โBREAKING: Stephen Miller Replaces Susie Wiles as Trumpโs Chief of Staff.โ โ โStephen Miller Replaces Susie Wiles as Trumpโs Chief of Staff.โ
- The Sun (4 wordings): โMILLER TIME Trump's post-midterms purge begins as he ousts Susie Wiles & installs ICE raid architect Stephen Miller as chief of staffโ โ โMAKING MOVES Trumpโs deputy chief of staff Richard Walters QUITS in major White House exit The departure marks the beginning of a major changing of the guard inside the West Wingโ
- The Washington Post (10 wordings): โTrump names Stephen Miller new White House chief of staffโ โ โStephen Miller starts job as chief of staff; GOP lawmaker calls new role a โmistakeโ - The Washington Postโ
- Townhall (3 wordings): โTrump Announces a New White House Chief of Staffโ โ โWhy Stephen Miller Replaced Susie Wiles As White House Chief of Staffโ
- USA Today (3 wordings): โTrump taps Stephen Miller to replace Susie Wiles as chief of staffโ โ โWiles is the latest high-profile woman to leave Trump administrationโ
- Washington Examiner (3 wordings): โStephen Miller to replace Susie Wiles as White House chief of staffโ โ โโFear and vitriolโ: Democrats trash Stephen Miller as new Trump chief of staffโ
- Yahoo News (7 wordings): โTrump replaces Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as White House chief of staffโ โ โTrump's new chief of staff signals a tougher immigration crackdown, officials sayโ
๐ฐ Every outlet's headline 70left to right by AllSides rating
Alternet๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Likely 'to go very badly': Critics gobsmacked as Miller becomes chief of staff
HuffPost๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Stephen Miller Will Replace Susie Wiles As Trump's Chief Of Staff
Mother Jones๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Hell on Earth: Stephen Miller Is Trumpโs New Chief of Staff
New York Magazine๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Is Making Stephen Miller His Chief of Staff: Live Updates Here are the latest post-midterms developments.
Raw Story๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump dumps Susie Wiles and hands the White House to Stephen Miller after midterm rout
Rolling Stone๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump's First Big Post-Midterms Move Is Promoting Stephen Miller
The Atlantic๐ Nov 6, 5 PM ET
Trump Doubles Down With Miller
The Bulwark๐ Nov 6, 5 PM ET
Sam Stein BREAKING: Trump Picks Stephen Miller to Replace Susie Wiles as Chief of Staff A recording from The Bulwarkโs live video
The Daily Beast๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Fires Susie Wiles and Promotes Reviled Aide in White House Purge
The Daily Kos๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Stephen Miller, Trumpโs top bigot, gets a big promotion
The Guardian๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Democrats blast Trumpโs decision to appoint Stephen Miller as chief of staff in wake of Republican midterm rout
The New Republic๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Promotes Stephen Miller as He Doubles Down on Extreme Agenda
Vox๐ Nov 6, 7 PM ET
Trump doubles down on everything that lost him the midterms
ABC News๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
Trump says chief of staff Susie Wiles out
Axios๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump replaces chief of staff Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller
CBS News๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump installs Stephen Miller as chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles
CNN๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Breaking News Stephen Miller will become White House chief of staff, Trump announces The move comes three days after Republicans suffered catastrophic losses in the midterm elections
Los Angeles Times๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
Trump taps Stephen Miller as chief of staff, doubling down after midterm rout
Mediaite๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
BREAKING: Trump Reveals Susie Wiles is OUT as WH Chief of Staff โ And Stephen Miller is IN
NBC News๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
Trump names Stephen Miller his new chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles
NPR๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Stephen Miller will replace Susie Wiles as Trump's chief of staff
New York Times๐ Nov 6, 7 PM ET
What to Know About Stephen Miller, Trumpโs New Chief of Staff
PBS NewsHour๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump names Stephen Miller his next chief of staff after major Republican midterm losses
Politico๐ Nov 6, 6 PM ET
Stephen Millerโs rise to chief of staff indicates Trump isnโt ready to move on
Semafor๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump elevates Stephen Miller after midterms disaster- Star Tribune๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET Trump replaces Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as chief of staff after GOP's midterm defeat
The Independent๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump axes chief of staff Susie Wiles for Stephen Miller after resounding midterms defeat
The Washington Post๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump names Stephen Miller new White House chief of staff- The Week๐ Nov 9, 3 PM ET Donald Trump shrugs off midterms with Stephen Miller appointment Talking Points The new chief of staff will โdouble down on Trumpismโ
Time๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
Stephen Miller to Be Trump's New Chief of Staff, Replacing Susie Wiles
USA Today๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump taps Stephen Miller to replace Susie Wiles as chief of staff
Yahoo News๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump replaces Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff
BBC๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump names Stephen Miller as new chief of staff
Bloomberg๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
Trump Taps Stephen Miller to Replace Wiles as Chief of Staff
Chicago Tribune๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
President Donald Trump replaces Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as chief of staff after GOPโs midterm defeat- Financial Times๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET Trump to replace Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as chief of staff
Forbes๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
Stephen Miller Replaces Susie Wiles As White House Chief Of Staff
News Nation๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Who is Stephen Miller, Trump's incoming White House chief of staff?
Newsweek๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Stephen Miller Replaces Susie Wiles as White House Chief of Staff
Reason๐ Nov 6, 5 PM ET
As Chief of Staff, Stephen Miller Will Reinforce Trump's Worst Instincts
Reuters๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump promotes Stephen Miller to post of chief of staff
Scripps News๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump names Stephen Miller chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles
Tampa Bay Times๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Florida veteran politico Susie Wiles exiting Trump White House โข News comment
The Hill๐ Nov 5, 6 PM ET
Former Trump staffer calls for Wiles to resign over midterm wipeout
Just the News๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
Trump names Stephen Miller as next chief of staff, starting Monday
The American Conservative๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Names Stephen Miller New Chief of Staff
The Epoch Times๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
Trump Names Stephen Miller to Replace Susie Wiles as Chief of Staff
The Free Press๐ Nov 8, 11 PM ET
Donald Trump Doubles Down
The Sun๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
MILLER TIME Trump's post-midterms purge begins as he ousts Susie Wiles & installs ICE raid architect Stephen Miller as chief of staff
The Washington Times๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
Susie Wiles out as Trump's chief of staff, replaced by Stephen Miller
Washington Examiner๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
Stephen Miller to replace Susie Wiles as White House chief of staff
Breitbart๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Miller Time: Stephen New Chief of Staff Wiles Out in Post-Election Shake-up
Fox News๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump taps Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles
New York Post๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
President Trump on Friday announced that he was replacing Susie Wiles as his chief of staff with his longtime adviser Stephen Miller following Republicansโ landslide midterm election loss.
Newsmax๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Replaces Wiles With Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff
OAN๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Susie Wiles departs WH Chief of Staff role, calls serving Trump an โHonorโ
PJ Media๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
BREAKING: Susie Wiles Out as Chief of Staff, Trump Names Replacement
Red State๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
BREAKING Big News: Susie Wiles Out As WH Chief of Staff (Updated)
The Blaze๐ Nov 9, 3 PM ET
3 times Trump's new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, proved himself a MAGA asset โ and a terror to the left
The Daily Caller๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Taps Top Immigration Adviser As New Chief Of Staff
The Daily Signal๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
BREAKING: Trump Picks New Chief of Staff
The Daily Wire๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Susie Wiles Out, Stephen Miller In As White House Chief Of Staff
The Federalist๐ Nov 6, 5 PM ET
Stephen Miller To Take Over As White House Chief Of Staff
The Gateway Pundit๐ Nov 6, 2 PM ET
BREAKING: Susie Wiles OUT as Trump Chief of Staff โ Stephen Miller to Take on Role
The National Pulse๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
BREAKING: Stephen Miller Replaces Susie Wiles as Trumpโs Chief of Staff.
The Post Millennial๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
BREAKING: Stephen Miller to replace Susie Wiles as Trump's chief of staff
The Western Journal๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Breaking: Susie Wiles Out as Trump's Chief of Staff, Replacement Named
Townhall๐ Nov 6, 3 PM ET
Trump Announces a New White House Chief of Staff- Washington Reporter๐ Nov 8, 1 PM ET EDITORIAL: Stephen Miller is the right pick for chief of staff
Zeteo๐ Nov 6, 4 PM ET
BREAKING: Trump Names Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff
๐ก Broadcast
TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it
- left
- leans left
- center
- right
๐บ On TV
minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean
๐ป On the radio
hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order
๐๏ธ On the shows
podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation
๐ต๏ธ Investigated, joked about
๐ต๏ธ investigative reporting on it and ๐ satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces
๐งถ Retelling
what people online made of it
๐งฉ How it's being told
The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.
- ๐งฉ All civil officers are impeachable
๐งถ online
as told: โThe White House chief of staff is said to be a civil officer liable to impeachment; others say impeachment reaches only Senate-confirmed officials.โ - ๐งฉ Appeal to Hitler
๐งถ online
โ๏ธ its answer: Words mean things
as told: โKatie Miller is stopping her podcast because her husband Stephen Miller is becoming Trump's chief of staff.โ and 3 more - ๐งฉ Buckle up
๐งถ online
as told: โStephen Miller is an evil and dangerous person whose influence will make things infinitely worse.โ - ๐งฉ Doubling down
๐งถ online
โ๏ธ its answer: They backed down
as told: โAfter the midterm losses, Trump replaced chief of staff Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller, architect of the rejected policies; her ally Richard Walters is leaving.โ - ๐งฉ Good riddance
๐งถ online
as told: โKatie Miller is stopping her podcast because her husband Stephen Miller is becoming Trump's chief of staff.โ - ๐งฉ Palace intrigue
๐งถ online
as told: โAfter the midterm losses, Trump replaced chief of staff Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller, architect of the rejected policies; her ally Richard Walters is leaving.โ - ๐งฉ Self-hating minority
๐งถ online
as told: โStephen Miller is a Jewish Nazi and the face of hatred that fuels white nationalists.โ and 1 more - ๐งฉ The enemy of all mankind
๐งถ online
as told: โStephen Miller is a Jewish Nazi and the face of hatred that fuels white nationalists.โ and 2 more - ๐งฉ The people's lawyer
๐งถ online
as told: โThe Attorney General is said to have called himself Stephen Miller's lawyer, when the AG should be the people's lawyer, not anyone's.โ - ๐งฉ Twenty-fifth amendment now!
๐งถ online
as told: โThe White House chief of staff is said to be a civil officer liable to impeachment; others say impeachment reaches only Senate-confirmed officials.โ
Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.
Donald TrumpStephen MillerSusie WilesTrump campaign
๐ Checking
what the fact-checkers looked into
No fact-checker has taken it on yet.
๐งต Persistence
the running story it belongs to
๐งต White House chief of staff controversy โ
- 1
- 2
Nov 6, 2 PM ET ยท ๐ this story
Trump names Stephen Miller as new White House chief of staff
- 3