← back to the front page › 🧵 Alaska Senate Race Dispute, story 3 of 13

🗞️ Story file #1098

Federal judge dismisses DOJ lawsuit over Alaska Senate race

Oct 27, 7 AM ET to Nov 4, 6 AM ET · 3 outlets not rated for lean

🗣️ in it: Donald TrumpMary PeltolaAlaskaDan SullivanSenate

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

🕰️ Crossed the aisle in 29 hours: first on the right (National Review, 7:00 AM), on the left by Oct 28, 12:00 PM (New York Times).

📰 read it at: HuffPostNew York MagazineRaw StorySlateThe GuardianABC NewsAPAxiosCBS NewsCNBCCNNLos Angeles TimesMediaiteNBC NewsNPRNew York TimesPBS NewsHourThe IndependentThe Washington PostTimeUSA TodayYahoo NewsBBCBloombergChicago TribuneFinancial TimesFortuneNews NationNewsweekReasonReutersScripps NewsThe HillJust the NewsNational ReviewThe Epoch TimesThe SunThe Washington TimesWashington ExaminerBreitbartFox NewsIJRNew York PostNewsmaxOANPJ MediaRed StateThe BlazeThe Daily CallerThe Daily SignalThe Daily WireThe FederalistThe Gateway PunditThe National DeskThe Post MillennialThe Western JournalTownhallCrooks and LiarsStraight Arrow NewsThe Washington Sun

  1. Oct 27, 7 AM ET

    first on a front page: National Review

  2. Oct 28, 6 PM ET

    first on TV: Fox News

  3. Oct 28, 7 PM ET

    the news that day, Newsmax:

    “Trump Demands Action on Peltola in Alaska Race”

  4. Oct 28, 7 PM ET

    first on the radio: ABC News Update

  5. Oct 29, 5 AM ET

    the news that day, HuffPost:

    “Alaska Governor Orders Peltola Campaign Probe Over NYT Report”

  6. Oct 30, 12 AM ET

    the news that day, The Washington Sun:

    “Peltola Denies Knowing About Alaska Spoiler Candidate”

  7. Oct 30, 9 AM ET

    peak: on 52 front pages at once

  8. Oct 31, 11 AM ET

    the news that day, Washington Examiner:

    “DOJ insists it wants Alaska ballots preserved, not changing votes”

  9. Nov 1, 6 PM ET

    the news that day, Washington Examiner:

    “Judge dismisses DOJ bid to delay Alaska Senate results if GOP loses”

  10. Nov 2, 1 PM ET

    the news that day, Reason:

    “Federal Judge Dismisses DOJ Lawsuit Over Alaska Senate Race, Calling Proposed Remedy 'Infeasible'”

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

📡 Wire copy

6 outlets ran the AP, Reuters headline nearly word for word

Chicago Tribune, HuffPost, Just the News, NPR, The Daily Signal, The Washington Sun

💬 Quoted

  1. “Infeasible”1
  2. “Decoy Dan”1
  3. “impossible”1
  4. “other”1
  5. “intensely”1
  6. “meritless”1
  7. “not even possible”1
  8. “Meritless”1

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

🗣️ Only one side says

  • 🫏 left
  • nothing of its own
  • 🐘 right
  • decoy dan

phrases three or more outlets on one side used and none on the other

📌 Linked by aggregators

4 Google News · Political Wire · Drudge Report · Real Clear Politics

aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)

📡 How outlets rewrote the wire: Reuters’s headline and the 4 versions furthest from it
  1. News Nation🕒 Oct 29, 6 AM ET

    Democrats Alaska man says Democratic operative recruited spoilers him to run in Alaska Senate race NYT says

  2. NBC News🕒 Oct 30, 6 PM ET

    Democrats recruited spoilers U.S. attorney says criminal investigation moving forward in Alaska Senate race NYT says

  3. Crooks and Liars🕒 Nov 2, 7 AM ET

    Democrats recruited spoilers Judge Tosses DOJ Lawsuit In Alaska Senate Race NYT says

  4. Bloomberg🕒 Oct 29, 12 PM ET

    GOP House Oversight Chair Probes Democrats recruited spoilers in Alaska Senate Race NYT says

The outlets whose headline changed the wire’s words the most, while keeping enough of them (three in ten or more) to be its version and not a headline of their own. Struck words are the wire’s, cut; words in pencil are the outlet’s own.

✏️ 53 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • ABC News (5 wordings): “Peltola campaign under fire after report it recruited 2nd Dan Sullivan in Senate race” → “Peltola denies knowing of 'any other candidate' on ballot besides herself, incumbent”
  • AP (11 wordings): “Trump says Alaska Dem Senate candidate should quit race, face prosecution” → “FBI visits Dan J. Sullivan donor in candidate’s hometown as Alaska Senate inquiry widens - AP News”
  • Axios (4 wordings): “Trump accuses Dems of perjury in Dan Sullivan race, governor orders probe” → “DOJ's Alaska ballot-confusion suit dismissed by judge”
  • BBC (5 wordings): “Alaska governor orders probe into Democratic campaign's alleged links to rival candidate” → “Judge dismisses Trump administration's lawsuit over two Dan Sullivans in Alaska election”
  • Bloomberg (5 wordings): “Trump Calls for Peltola to Be Banned From Alaska Senate Race” → “DOJ Lawsuit to Probe Alaska Senate Vote Thrown Out by Judge”
  • Breitbart (9 wordings): “Report: Alaska Democrats Made Plan to Find Second Dan Sullivan Candidate” → “Trump: Peltola Should Be Prosecuted over Dem Scheme to Recruit 2nd Dan Sullivan into Alaska Senate Race…”
  • CBS News (9 wordings): “Trump says Peltola "shouldn't be allowed to run" due to second Dan Sullivan” → “Judge tosses lawsuit seeking to delay certification of Alaska Senate race”
  • CNBC (7 wordings): “Peltola campaign aides, DSCC officials helped recruit second Dan Sullivan in Alaska race: NYT” → “Judge dismisses Alaska Senate election lawsuit; DOJ vows appeal”
  • CNN (9 wordings): “Analysis Alaska Democrats played into Trump’s hands with Dan Sullivan ballot-stacking effort Alaska Democrats gave Donald Trump exactly what he wanted” → “Judge throws out DOJ attempt to delay certification of Alaska Senate race A federal judge on Sunday threw out the DOJ's lawsuit seeking to segregate ballots and delay certification of Alaska's Senate race”
  • Chicago Tribune (5 wordings): “Trump calls for prosecution of Democratic Alaska Senate candidate over spoiler candidate controversy” → “Judge dismisses Trump-backed lawsuit seeking to block certification of Alaska’s US Senate race if GOP incumbent loses”
  • Financial Times (2 wordings): “Trump calls for Alaska Democratic candidate to be banned from Senate race” → “Uproar in Alaska sparks Democratic fears for Senate majority”
  • Fox News (14 wordings): “Trump accused of trying to 'force' Senate candidate on voters as GOP feud erupts” → “DOJ responds after judge's ruling in 'Decoy Dan' Alaska Senate controversy”
  • HuffPost (13 wordings): “Trump Demands Mary Peltola Be Taken Off Alaska Senate Race Ballot After NYT Report” → “Judge Dismisses DOJ’s Bonkers Alaska Senate Race Lawsuit”
  • Independent Journal Review (3 wordings): “DOJ Sues Over Alaska Senate Ballot Dispute” → “DOJ Probes Alaska Senate Ballot Dispute”
  • Just the News (9 wordings): “Trump says Peltola shouldn't be allowed to run after NYT's 'Dan Sullivan' report” → “Judges tosses DOJ attempt to block Alaska Senate results if GOP incumbent loses”
  • Los Angeles Times (3 wordings): “Mary Peltola’s campaign reportedly helped recruit second Dan Sullivan for Alaska Senate race” → “Attorneys for GOP-run Alaska say ‘meritless’ Trump demand to set aside Senate ballots ‘not even possible’”
  • Mediaite (5 wordings): “‘A FRAUD ON THE AMERICAN PUBLIC!’ Trump Issues Fiery Call for Alaska Dem to Be Thrown Off Ballot After NYT Exposes Campaign’s Dirty Trick” → “BREAKING: Judge Throws Out Trump Administration Lawsuit to Delay Certification in Alaska Senate Race if Dan Sullivan Loses”
  • NBC News (2 wordings): “U.S. attorney for Alaska gives update on Dan J. Sullivan ballot investigation” → “U.S. attorney says criminal investigation moving forward in Alaska Senate race”
  • NPR (4 wordings): “Alaska's all-important Senate race is roiled by a report on alleged spoiler candidate” → “Judge tosses Trump's attempt to block Alaska Senate results if GOP incumbent loses”
  • New York Post (11 wordings): “Alaska governor orders probe of Mary Peltola Senate campaign over ‘Decoy Dan’ Sullivan scandal” → “DOJ suit tossed as feds fought certification of Alaska Senate race over ‘Decoy Dan’ Sullivan scandal”
  • New York Times (6 wordings): “Inside Democrats’ Secret Effort to Stack Alaska’s Midterm Ballot With Another Dan Sullivan” → “Judge Rejects Trump Officials’ Move to Challenge Alaska Senate Election”
  • News Nation (6 wordings): “Peltola denies report her campaign worked to recruit another 'Dan Sullivan'” → “Judge dismisses lawsuit seeking to block certification of Alaska Senate race if GOP incumbent loses”
  • Newsmax (15 wordings): “Trump Demands Action Against Peltola Over Alaska Race” → “Judge Tosses DOJ Lawsuit Over Alaska Senate Race”
  • Newsweek (6 wordings): “Trump Responds After Bombshell Report on Alaska’s Two Dan Sullivans Dispute” → “Trump Bid to Block Alaska Senate Results Rejected by Obama-Appointed Judge”
  • One America News Network (3 wordings): “Alaska Senate race: Peltola’s campaign denies NYT report claiming her staff and allied operatives worked to recruit namesake spoiler candidate” → “Judge rejects lawsuit seeking to halt Alaska Senate election certification amid 'Decoy Dan' controversy”
  • PBS NewsHour (3 wordings): “WATCH: Trump calls for Peltola to drop out after report her campaign helped recruit 2nd Dan Sullivan” → “Republicans seize on controversy in Alaska's closely watched Senate race”
  • PJ Media (3 wordings): “Report: Democrat Campaign Recruited ‘Decoy Dan’ Sullivan to Run in Alaska” → “Trump Calls for Disqualification and Prosecution of Peltola, ‘Decoy Dan’ in Alaska Senate Race”
  • Raw Story (2 wordings): “GOP governor launches probe into Democrat's campaign after Trump cries 'voter fraud'” → “Trump's Alaska gambit falls apart as federal judge throws out election lawsuit”
  • Reason (4 wordings): “To Confuse Voters, Mary Peltola's Campaign Recruited a Second Dan Sullivan” → “Federal Judge Dismisses DOJ Lawsuit Over Alaska Senate Race, Calling Proposed Remedy 'Infeasible'”
  • Red State (7 wordings): “Democrats' Secret Plan to Stack Alaska Senate Ballot With Spoilers” → “Federal Judge Dismisses DOJ Lawsuit Over Alaska Senate Certification”
  • Reuters (4 wordings): “Democrats recruited spoilers in Alaska Senate race, NYT says” → “US judge dismisses Trump election lawsuit in Alaska”
  • Scripps News (4 wordings): “Report: Peltola linked to effort to recruit second Dan Sullivan in Senate race” → “DOJ pushes to isolate Alaska ballots over potential voter confusion”
  • Straight Arrow News (2 wordings): “Peltola denies scheme to confuse voters as DOJ widens probe into Alaska Senate race” → “Federal judge throws out DOJ’s lawsuit asking to segregate ballots in Alaska Senate race”
  • The Blaze (2 wordings): “Democrat Peltola feeling the heat as Alaska launches CRIMINAL probe into alleged 'Decoy Dan' ballot scheme” → “Alaska may 'stop' election certification due to alleged Democratic 'Decoy Dan' scheme: Governor”
  • The Daily Caller (2 wordings): “Editor Daily Rundown: Democratic Operatives Tracked Down Second Dan Sullivan For Alaska Ballot, Report Says” → “Governor Orders Investigation Into Dem Senate Nominee’s Ballot Scheme”
  • The Daily Signal (2 wordings): “Ex-Peltola Aide Alleges Candidate Knew About Recruiting the ‘Other Dan Sullivan’” → “US Judge Dismisses Trump Election Lawsuit in Alaska”
  • The Daily Wire (5 wordings): “Trump Accuses Dems Of ‘Fake’ Candidate Scheme In Crucial Senate Race” → “Obama-Appointed Judge Rules Against Trump In Alaska ‘Decoy Dan’ Fight”
  • The Epoch Times (10 wordings): “Trump Calls for Legal Action Against Peltola Campaign Over Alleged Name-Confusion Scheme in Alaska Senate Race” → “Federal Judge Dismisses DOJ’s Lawsuit Over Alaska Senate Race”
  • The Federalist (2 wordings): “Breaking News Alert *** Breaking *** Sen. Johnson Launches Probe Into Alaska's 'Decoy Dan' Senate Race Scandal Breaking ***” → “4 Trending: Sen. Johnson Launches Probe Into Alaska’s ‘Decoy Dan’ Senate Race Scandal”
  • The Gateway Pundit (6 wordings): “NEW: DOJ Launches Criminal Investigation Into Alaska Senate Decoy Candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Amid NYT Bombshell Revealing Peltola’s Camp Recruited the Saboteur” → “JUST IN: Radical Obama Judge Tosses DOJ’s Alaska Lawsuit Over Decoy Dan Sullivan”
  • The Guardian (8 wordings): “Trump rages at Alaska Democrat whose campaign reportedly recruited man with same name as Republican opponent” → “Judge dismisses Trump attempt to block Alaska Senate race results if Republican loses”
  • The Hill (13 wordings): “Trump calls alleged Alaska Senate spoiler scheme ‘voter fraud at the highest level’” → “Feds ‘intensely’ probing alleged Alaska ballot scheme, US attorney confirms”
  • The Independent (6 wordings): “Trump demands Alaska ballot change after report on Dems recruiting Dan Sullivan to campaign” → “Judge tosses Justice Department lawsuit over Alaska’s two Dan Sullivans on the Senate ballot”
  • The National Desk (6 wordings): “Fact Check Team: DOJ lawsuit challenges Alaska Senate election certification if GOP loses” → “Judge dismisses Trump administration bid to block Alaska Senate race certification”
  • The Post Millennial (2 wordings): “NY Times admits Dem operatives are behind effort to recruit ‘spoiler’ Alaska candidate with same name as GOP Sen Dan Sullivan” → “Son of Alaska’s ‘Decoy’ Dan Sullivan works for Dem Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez”
  • The Sun (2 wordings): “DIRTY POLITICS Trump furious after Dems 'recruit candidate with same name' for crunch vote” → “DIRTY POLITICS Trump furious after Dems 'recruit candidate with same name' for crunch vote OTHER Alaskans with different names were also reportedly approached, apparently to add more options to the ballot.”
  • The Washington Post (8 wordings): “Report on recruiting a ‘spoiler’ shakes up Senate race in Alaska” → “Judge tosses DOJ’s attempt to delay Alaska’s Senate results if Republican loses - The Washington Post”
  • The Washington Sun (7 wordings): “Trump Says Peltola Should Face ‘Legal and Political Consequences’ for Dan Sullivan Recruitment” → “Judge Dismisses a Trump-Backed Lawsuit in the Alaska Ballot Case”
  • The Washington Times (3 wordings): “Trump seizes on 'fake' Dan Sullivan report, calls for Peltola's removal from Alaska ballot” → “Judge tosses Trump DOJ's challenge to 'other' Dan Sullivan on Alaska ballot”
  • The Western Journal (4 wordings): “Alaska Dems Spent Months Finding a Duplicate 'Dan Sullivan' to Confuse GOP Voters Ahead of Senate Race” → “Trump Calls for Dem Senate Candidate to be Prosecuted: 'Voter Fraud at the Highest Level'”
  • Townhall (8 wordings): “Democrats in Alaska Think Voters Are Stupid” → “Decoy Dan Sullivan Flees Home Amid Election-Rigging Scandal in Alaska”
  • Washington Examiner (12 wordings): “Trump: Peltola and other Dan Sullivan should be thrown off the ballot” → “Judge dismisses DOJ bid to delay Alaska Senate results if GOP loses”
  • Yahoo News (9 wordings): “Alaska Democrats linked to secret effort to recruit 2nd Dan Sullivan to tip Senate race: Report” → “Judge throws out DOJ attempt to delay certification of Alaska Senate race”
📰 Every outlet's headline 60left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. 🫏 CNN 456 min
  2. 🐘 Fox News 197 min
  3. 🫏 MSNOW 30 min
  4. ⚖️ BBC News 14 min

📻 On the radio

hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order

  1. 🫏 ABC News Update 36× · 🥇 led 10
  2. 🫏 NPR News Now 34× · 🥇 led 8

🎙️ On the shows

podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation

  1. ⚖️ Bloomberg News Now 6
  2. 🫏 MeidasTouch 3
  3. 🐘 Morning Wire 2
  4. 🫏 CNN 5 Things 2
  5. ⚖️ Up First (NPR) 1
  6. 🐘 Ben Shapiro 1
  7. 🐘 Erick Erickson 1

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces

  1. 🃏 The Onion 1

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

  • 🧩 Checks and balances 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Executive overreach
    as told: “A federal judge dismissed the Department of Justice's lawsuit seeking to block the certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate race if Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan loses.”
  • 🧩 Executive overreach 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Checks and balances
    as told: “A federal judge dismissed the Department of Justice's lawsuit seeking to block the certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate race if Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan loses.”
  • 🧩 Laying the groundwork 🧶 online
    as told: “The Department of Justice is trying to steal Alaska ballots or insult Alaskan voters by claiming they cannot distinguish between candidates.”
  • 🧩 They think you're stupid 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Too stupid to understand, Spoiler candidate
    as told: “The Department of Justice is trying to steal Alaska ballots or insult Alaskan voters by claiming they cannot distinguish between candidates.” and 1 more
  • 🧩 They're going to steal it 🧶 online
    as told: “The Department of Justice is trying to steal Alaska ballots or insult Alaskan voters by claiming they cannot distinguish between candidates.”

Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

    Oct 28, 6 PM ET · 📍 this story

    Federal judge dismisses DOJ lawsuit over Alaska Senate race

  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13