🧵 Saga file #79
New York City carriage ban Oct 13, 10 PM ET to Nov 21, 3 AM ET
🔔 Notify me
🧵 One running story, told across days: each of its stories is on the front pages
in its own right, joined to the others because our tools judged them one case, event or investigation as it
developed. A story can be joined wrongly; the saga tracker says how they're made.
🧩 5 stories so far 📰 32 outlets carried one ⚖️ 🫏14 · 6 · 11🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 38.2 days running so far 📺 11 min of TV captions 📻 9 radio newscasts 📰 Spread each story on the front pages, hour by hour
12 25 Oct 19 Oct 26 Nov 2 Nov 9 Nov 16 peak: 25 front pages, Fri 4 AM Tue Oct 13, 4 PM ET: on 1 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 1
“NYC Central Park’s horse-drawn carriages to be banned under new Mamdani deal” (New York Post) Tue Oct 13, 7 PM ET: on 5 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 5
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal” (Bloomberg) Tue Oct 13, 10 PM ET: on 6 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 6
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal” (Bloomberg) Wed Oct 14, 1 AM ET: on 7 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 7
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal” (Bloomberg) Wed Oct 14, 4 AM ET: on 8 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 8
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal” (Bloomberg) Wed Oct 14, 7 AM ET: on 9 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 9
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal” (Bloomberg) Wed Oct 14, 10 AM ET: on 10 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 10
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal” (Bloomberg) Wed Oct 14, 1 PM ET: on 12 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 12
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028, City Council speaker says” (ABC News) Wed Oct 14, 4 PM ET: on 14 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 14
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028, City Council speaker says” (ABC News) Wed Oct 14, 7 PM ET: on 16 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 16
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Wed Oct 14, 10 PM ET: on 15 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 15
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 1 AM ET: on 16 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 16
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 4 AM ET: on 16 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 16
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 7 AM ET: on 16 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 16
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 10 AM ET: on 14 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 14
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 1 PM ET: on 12 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 12
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 4 PM ET: on 9 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 9
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 7 PM ET: on 6 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 6
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 15, 10 PM ET: on 6 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 6
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Fri Oct 16, 1 AM ET: on 7 front pages
1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: 7
“New York City moves to ban horse-drawn carriages” (The Guardian) Thu Oct 22, 10 AM ET: on 2 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 2
“End of an era as NYC finally moves to ban Central Park horse-drawn carriages” (The Independent) Thu Oct 22, 1 PM ET: on 2 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 2
“End of an era as NYC finally moves to ban Central Park horse-drawn carriages” (The Independent) Thu Oct 22, 4 PM ET: on 6 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 4
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 2
“Trump laments NYC horse-drawn carriage ban” (The Hill) Thu Oct 22, 7 PM ET: on 18 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 15
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 3
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Thu Oct 22, 10 PM ET: on 21 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 18
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 3
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 1 AM ET: on 24 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 21
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 3
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 4 AM ET: on 25 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 22
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 3
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 7 AM ET: on 25 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 22
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 3
“NYC to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 10 AM ET: on 25 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 22
2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: 3
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 1 PM ET: on 22 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 22
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 4 PM ET: on 20 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 20
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 7 PM ET: on 20 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 20
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Fri Oct 23, 10 PM ET: on 19 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 19
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 1 AM ET: on 19 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 19
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 4 AM ET: on 19 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 19
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 7 AM ET: on 18 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 18
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 10 AM ET: on 14 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 14
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 1 PM ET: on 9 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 9
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 4 PM ET: on 9 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 9
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 7 PM ET: on 7 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 7
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sat Oct 24, 10 PM ET: on 7 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 7
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sun Oct 25, 1 AM ET: on 7 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 7
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sun Oct 25, 4 AM ET: on 6 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 6
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Sun Oct 25, 7 AM ET: on 6 front pages
3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: 6
“New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028” (ABC News) Thu Nov 19, 12 PM ET: on 2 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 2
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 3 PM ET: on 3 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 3
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 6 PM ET: on 5 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 5
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 9 PM ET: on 5 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 5
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 12 AM ET: on 6 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 6
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 3 AM ET: on 6 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 6
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 6 AM ET: on 6 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 6
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 9 AM ET: on 7 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 7
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 12 PM ET: on 7 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 7
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 3 PM ET: on 7 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 7
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 6 PM ET: on 8 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 7
5. New York bans horse-drawn carriages: 1
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 9 PM ET: on 6 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 5
5. New York bans horse-drawn carriages: 1
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Sat Nov 21, 12 AM ET: on 6 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 5
5. New York bans horse-drawn carriages: 1
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Sat Nov 21, 3 AM ET: on 6 front pages
4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: 5
5. New York bans horse-drawn carriages: 1
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) 2. New York City bans horse-drawn carriages 2 3. New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028 3 1. New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028 1 5. New York bans horse-drawn carriages 5 4. Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park 4 Front pages carrying each story at each hourly look, Oct 13, 4 PM to Nov 21, 3 AM ET:
its stories stacked, the oldest at the bottom, each numbered at its busiest hour as in the list below.
Point at an hour for what the front pages said then. Oct 14 Oct 16 Oct 18 Oct 20 Oct 22 Oct 24 Oct 26 Oct 28 Oct 30 Nov 1 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 1. New York City to ban horse-drawn …New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028 New York City to ban horse-drawn carriages in 2028: Oct 13, 10 PM to Oct 16, 3 AM ET, 19 outlets 2. New York City bans horse-drawn ca…New York City bans horse-drawn carriages New York City bans horse-drawn carriages: Oct 22, 8 PM to Oct 23, 11 AM ET, 3 outlets 3. New York City Council passes hors…New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028 New York City Council passes horse-drawn carriage ban by 2028: Oct 22, 6 PM to Oct 25, 7 AM ET, 25 outlets 4. Mayor signs law banning horse car…Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park: Nov 19, 11 PM to Nov 21, 3 AM ET, 7 outlets 5. New York bans horse-drawn carriag…New York bans horse-drawn carriages New York bans horse-drawn carriages: Nov 20, 5 PM to Nov 21, 3 AM ET, 1 outlets 📺 TV CNN, Oct 14, 5:24 AM ET: Vote Scheduled On Ban Of New York City’s Horse-Drawn Carriages In Central Park CNN, Oct 14, 5:25 AM ET: Vote Scheduled On Ban Of New York City’s Horse-Drawn Carriages In Central Park CNN, Oct 14, 6:53 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES CNN, Oct 14, 6:57 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES CNN, Oct 14, 6:58 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES CNN, Oct 14, 6:58 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES CNN, Oct 14, 6:59 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES CNN, Oct 14, 6:59 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES. Julie Menin | (D) New York City Council Speaker CNN, Oct 14, 6:59 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES. Julie Menin | (D) New York City Council Speaker CNN, Oct 14, 7:00 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES CNN, Oct 14, 7:00 PM ET: NYC MOVES CLOSER TO BANNING ITS ICONIC HORSE-DRAWN CARRIAGES Fox News, Oct 22, 6:12 PM ET: CARRIAGE CONTROVERSY. NEW YORK CITY COUNCIL VOTES TO PHASE OUT HORSE CABS BBC News, Oct 22, 6:49 PM ET: NY set to ban horse-drawn carriage rides BBC News, Oct 22, 6:50 PM ET: NY set to ban horse-drawn carriage rides BBC News, Oct 22, 7:00 PM ET: Horse-drawn carriage ban BBC News, Oct 22, 7:24 PM ET: NY set to ban horse-drawn carriage rides BBC News, Oct 22, 7:25 PM ET: NY set to ban horse-drawn carriage rides 📻 radio ABC News Update, Oct 14, 1:06 PM ET ABC News Update, Oct 14, 8:32 AM ET NPR News Now, Oct 23, 11:09 PM ET NPR News Now, Oct 23, 4:10 AM ET NPR News Now, Oct 23, 2:09 AM ET NPR News Now, Oct 22, 10:11 PM ET ABC News Update, Oct 22, 9:32 PM ET NPR News Now, Oct 22, 8:09 PM ET ABC News Update, Oct 22, 6:32 PM ET Its stories in the order of their latest news, each from when we first saw it on a front page to when we last
did; beneath, the TV captions, radio newscasts and retellings, each in the color of the story it was
about. Hover for details. 🧭 How it unfolded each day’s news in an outlet’s own headline, in the color of its story
1 Oct 13, 6 PM ET
“NYC Horse Carriages Set to Be Banned in 2028 After Deal”
Bloomberg
1 Oct 14, 5 PM ET
“N,Y. to Ban Central Park's Horse-Drawn Carriages After Teen's Death”
Newsmax
1 Oct 15, 12 PM ET
“Priorities! Mamdani Kills NYC Classic Horse Carriages ’Coming to an End’”
Breitbart
3 Oct 22, 5 PM ET
“A 160-year-old New York tradition is headed for extinction”
USA Today
3 Oct 23, 6 AM ET
“The ban will take hold on June 1, 2028 and outlaw horse-drawn carriages across all five boroughs.”
New York Post
4 Nov 19, 4 PM ET
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages”
Newsmax
5 Nov 20, 5 PM ET
“Mamdani Ends New York's Iconic Horse-Drawn Carriages”
Townhall
🧩 How it's been told the stories under the saga, day by day, from our motif index: each day its most-told, wider for more tellers, colored by genre (✨ new to the saga that day)
🎭 Archetypes a kind of person 📜 Plots what happened 🪨 Beliefs a premise 🕵️ Theories what people think is behind it 🗣️ Arguments a move in an argument ⚪ left white, the smaller genres: 📣 Exhortations a call to act Sat Oct 24
✨ Do your part 1 🧶 Retelling what people online made of it, story by story
Nobody's retelling any of it online yet, as far as the daily report can tell.